湖北经济学院学报
湖北經濟學院學報
호북경제학원학보
JOURNAL OF HUBER UNIVERSITY OF ECONOMICS
2012年
1期
10-13,58
,共5页
大卫·李嘉图%经济伦理%功利主义
大衛·李嘉圖%經濟倫理%功利主義
대위·리가도%경제윤리%공리주의
David Ricardo%economic ethics%utilitarianism
大卫·李嘉图开启了近现代自由贸易的全新时代,但对于李嘉图的经济伦理思想却鲜有梳理或是有所误读。李嘉图的经济伦理思想主要是功利主义的,其比较优势理论最为集中地体现了“最大多数人的最大幸福”原则,直到今天仍对诸多领域有一般性指导意义。然而,也有一些学者对其持审慎甚至批评的态度,并以“比较优势陷阱”误读李嘉图的经济伦理思想。这种误读从表层来说是使比较优势学说遭到了错误的质疑,从更深层来说则很有可能使得功利主义受到的诘难超越了其应该遭遇的尺度。
大衛·李嘉圖開啟瞭近現代自由貿易的全新時代,但對于李嘉圖的經濟倫理思想卻鮮有梳理或是有所誤讀。李嘉圖的經濟倫理思想主要是功利主義的,其比較優勢理論最為集中地體現瞭“最大多數人的最大倖福”原則,直到今天仍對諸多領域有一般性指導意義。然而,也有一些學者對其持審慎甚至批評的態度,併以“比較優勢陷阱”誤讀李嘉圖的經濟倫理思想。這種誤讀從錶層來說是使比較優勢學說遭到瞭錯誤的質疑,從更深層來說則很有可能使得功利主義受到的詰難超越瞭其應該遭遇的呎度。
대위·리가도개계료근현대자유무역적전신시대,단대우리가도적경제윤리사상각선유소리혹시유소오독。리가도적경제윤리사상주요시공리주의적,기비교우세이론최위집중지체현료“최대다수인적최대행복”원칙,직도금천잉대제다영역유일반성지도의의。연이,야유일사학자대기지심신심지비평적태도,병이“비교우세함정”오독리가도적경제윤리사상。저충오독종표층래설시사비교우세학설조도료착오적질의,종경심층래설칙흔유가능사득공리주의수도적힐난초월료기응해조우적척도。
David Ricardo opened the new era of modern free trade. However, there are little thought, or misreading about Ricardo's economic ethics. Ricardo's economic ethics mainly expressed utilitarianism, the principle of "the greatest happiness of the greatest number" is most clearly reflected by his theory of comparative advantage. The theory still has general signifi- cance towards many fields until today. But there are also some scholars hold a kind of careful or even critical attitude to- wards it, and misread Ricardo's economic ethics via "Comparative Advantage Trap". The misreading, from the apparently sense, makes the theory of comparative advantage be wrong questioned, and from a more profound point of view, probably makes utilitarianism be blamed beyond necessity.