贵州警官职业学院学报
貴州警官職業學院學報
귀주경관직업학원학보
JOURNAL OF GUIZHOU POLICE OFFICER VOCATIONAL COLLEGE
2011年
4期
82-88
,共7页
行政诉讼%协调和解%程序选择权%立法建议
行政訴訟%協調和解%程序選擇權%立法建議
행정소송%협조화해%정서선택권%입법건의
administrative suit%coordination reconciliation%procedure-choosing right%suggestion on legislation
行政诉讼协调和解作为一项探索性工作,在司法实践中很有生命力,但也存在一些问题:缺乏独立程序价值地位,片面追求"案结事了"的价值功能,某些规定有违正当程序原则。构建行政诉讼协调和解机制的理念基础是:明确行政诉讼协调和解内涵,赋予其独立诉讼程序地位,衡平纠纷解决与权力监督之间关系,借鉴域内外立法经验。具体规则设计应从以下几方面考虑:行政协调的原则、模式、范围、结案方式及救济途径;最终还需立法支持。
行政訴訟協調和解作為一項探索性工作,在司法實踐中很有生命力,但也存在一些問題:缺乏獨立程序價值地位,片麵追求"案結事瞭"的價值功能,某些規定有違正噹程序原則。構建行政訴訟協調和解機製的理唸基礎是:明確行政訴訟協調和解內涵,賦予其獨立訴訟程序地位,衡平糾紛解決與權力鑑督之間關繫,藉鑒域內外立法經驗。具體規則設計應從以下幾方麵攷慮:行政協調的原則、模式、範圍、結案方式及救濟途徑;最終還需立法支持。
행정소송협조화해작위일항탐색성공작,재사법실천중흔유생명력,단야존재일사문제:결핍독립정서개치지위,편면추구"안결사료"적개치공능,모사규정유위정당정서원칙。구건행정소송협조화해궤제적이념기출시:명학행정소송협조화해내함,부여기독립소송정서지위,형평규분해결여권력감독지간관계,차감역내외입법경험。구체규칙설계응종이하궤방면고필:행정협조적원칙、모식、범위、결안방식급구제도경;최종환수입법지지。
As an exploring work,the coordination reconciliation of administrative suit has its strong vitality in practices,but at the same time,it has some problems: lacking of independent position of procedural value,unilaterally pursuing the value function of finishing dealing with the cases,and some regulations coinciding with the principles of justice procedure.The principal bases of constructing coordination reconciliation system of administrative suit are: making clear the connotation of coordination reconciliation of administrative suit,giving it the independent position of suit procedure,balancing the relationship between dispute settlement and power supervision,and using the abroad legislative experiences for references.We should take the following into consideration: the principle,mode,scale,model of ending the case the relief ways,and finally the support of legislation.