未来与发展
未來與髮展
미래여발전
FUTURE AND DEVELOPMENT
2014年
5期
16-20
,共5页
定性评价%方法%同行评议%综述
定性評價%方法%同行評議%綜述
정성평개%방법%동행평의%종술
Qualitative Evaluation%Methods%Peer Review%Review
作为定性评价方法代表的同行评议是科学评价中使用最为广泛的方法,在使用中人们注意到其具有一些固有缺陷,并尝试进行了弥补。文章在对同行评议定义、同行评议专家遴选、同行评议局限性、网络同行评议等方面做文献研究的基础上,得出结论认为,定性与定量评价方法将在各自最为适用的领域发挥自身优势,并相互弥补不足,走向综合。
作為定性評價方法代錶的同行評議是科學評價中使用最為廣汎的方法,在使用中人們註意到其具有一些固有缺陷,併嘗試進行瞭瀰補。文章在對同行評議定義、同行評議專傢遴選、同行評議跼限性、網絡同行評議等方麵做文獻研究的基礎上,得齣結論認為,定性與定量評價方法將在各自最為適用的領域髮揮自身優勢,併相互瀰補不足,走嚮綜閤。
작위정성평개방법대표적동행평의시과학평개중사용최위엄범적방법,재사용중인문주의도기구유일사고유결함,병상시진행료미보。문장재대동행평의정의、동행평의전가린선、동행평의국한성、망락동행평의등방면주문헌연구적기출상,득출결론인위,정성여정량평개방법장재각자최위괄용적영역발휘자신우세,병상호미보불족,주향종합。
Peer review,as a typical representative of qualitative evaluation,is the most widely used method in evaluation of science.People notice that it has some connatural limitations and try to make amends.This article reviews peer review in the following aspects:the definition of peer review,the selection of peer review experts,the limitation of peer review and peer review through the Internet and gets the conclusion that qualitative and quantitative evaluation methods would play their advantages in their most suitable areas and compensate each other,towards integration.