中医临床研究
中醫臨床研究
중의림상연구
CLINICAL JOURNAL OF CHINESE MEDICINE
2013年
20期
119-121
,共3页
通窍%分泌性中耳炎%荟萃分析
通纖%分泌性中耳炎%薈萃分析
통규%분비성중이염%회췌분석
Tongqiao%Secretory otitis media%Meta-analysis
目的:系统评价通窍法为临床基础治则治疗分泌性中耳炎的临床优势及重要性。方法:通过检索CNKI和万方数据库,以“通窍法”和“分泌性中耳炎”以及“卡他性中耳炎”、“耳胀”等类似病名为主题词检索通窍法治疗分泌性中耳炎的随机对照临床研究报道,并辅以手工检索进行文献追踪。以常规治疗为对照组,通窍法治疗分泌性中耳炎为治疗组,提取纳入研究文献原始数据,并进行Meta分析。结果:4篇文献被纳入本次研究,共210例分泌性中耳炎患者,其中治疗组175例,对照组135例。Meta分析结果显示,通窍法治疗分泌性中耳炎效果优于常规治疗(P<0.0001),总有效率合并OR及其95%CI为1.25(1.13,1.40)。结论:通窍法治疗该病有优势,可作为治疗该病的基本准则,但仍需进一步进行科学研究。
目的:繫統評價通纖法為臨床基礎治則治療分泌性中耳炎的臨床優勢及重要性。方法:通過檢索CNKI和萬方數據庫,以“通纖法”和“分泌性中耳炎”以及“卡他性中耳炎”、“耳脹”等類似病名為主題詞檢索通纖法治療分泌性中耳炎的隨機對照臨床研究報道,併輔以手工檢索進行文獻追蹤。以常規治療為對照組,通纖法治療分泌性中耳炎為治療組,提取納入研究文獻原始數據,併進行Meta分析。結果:4篇文獻被納入本次研究,共210例分泌性中耳炎患者,其中治療組175例,對照組135例。Meta分析結果顯示,通纖法治療分泌性中耳炎效果優于常規治療(P<0.0001),總有效率閤併OR及其95%CI為1.25(1.13,1.40)。結論:通纖法治療該病有優勢,可作為治療該病的基本準則,但仍需進一步進行科學研究。
목적:계통평개통규법위림상기출치칙치료분비성중이염적림상우세급중요성。방법:통과검색CNKI화만방수거고,이“통규법”화“분비성중이염”이급“잡타성중이염”、“이창”등유사병명위주제사검색통규법치료분비성중이염적수궤대조림상연구보도,병보이수공검색진행문헌추종。이상규치료위대조조,통규법치료분비성중이염위치료조,제취납입연구문헌원시수거,병진행Meta분석。결과:4편문헌피납입본차연구,공210례분비성중이염환자,기중치료조175례,대조조135례。Meta분석결과현시,통규법치료분비성중이염효과우우상규치료(P<0.0001),총유효솔합병OR급기95%CI위1.25(1.13,1.40)。결론:통규법치료해병유우세,가작위치료해병적기본준칙,단잉수진일보진행과학연구。
Objective:To systematic review the clinical advantages and importance of Tongqiao therapy which as a basic clinical governance approach on treating secretory otitis media. Methods: By retrieving CNKI and Wanfang DATA, make “Tongqiao therapy”,“Secretory otitis media” and “ Catarrhal otitis media”, “ear swelling” as the keywords to search randomized controlled clinical study reported of treating secretory otitis media by Tongqiao therapy. The control group was given conventional therapy, treating secretory otitis media by Tongqiao therapy as the treated group, included in the research literature to extract the raw data and carry on Meta-analysis. Results: Four documents were included in the study, 210 patients with secretory otitis media in which the treated group 175 cases, 135 cases in the control group. Meta-analysis showed: The efficacy of Tongqiao therapy on treating secretory otitis media was better than conventional therapy (P<0.0001). The total efficiency pooled OR and 95%CI was 1.25 (1.13, 1.40). Conclusion:Tongqiao therapy to treat this disease has the advantage, can be used as basic guidelines for the treatment of the disease, but still need to further scientific research.