循证医学
循證醫學
순증의학
THE JOURNAL OF EVIDENCE-BASED MEDICINE
2014年
2期
104-108,128
,共6页
杨春艳%胡小平%韩凤珍%杜娟
楊春豔%鬍小平%韓鳳珍%杜娟
양춘염%호소평%한봉진%두연
硫酸镁%早产%胎儿神经保护%Meta分析
硫痠鎂%早產%胎兒神經保護%Meta分析
류산미%조산%태인신경보호%Meta분석
Magnesium Sulfate%preterm labor%fetus neuroprotection%meta-analysis
目的:系统分析产前使用硫酸镁对胎儿神经的保护作用。方法检索 PubMed、Cochrane 图书馆、EMBASE、中国期刊全文数据库、中国生物医学文献数据库、中文科技期刊全文数据库收录的公开发表与研究目的相关的随机对照研究文献,对满足条件的数据进行合并分析,Meta 分析软件用RevMan 5.0。评价指标包括:胎儿出生后18~24个月发生脑瘫并围产儿死亡、脑瘫、中-重度脑瘫、中-重度脑瘫并围产儿死亡、围产儿死亡,根据使用硫酸镁时的妊娠周数来分析其对胎儿神经系统的保护作用。结果5个随机对照研究(5235名胎儿/新生儿)纳入分析。妊娠30~34周使用硫酸镁并不能减少脑瘫并围产儿死亡的发生率(相对危险度0.93,95%可信区间0.79~1.09),但是单独发生的脑瘫(相对危险度0.70,95%可信区间0.54~0.90)、中-重度脑瘫(相对危险度0.61,95%可信区间0.44~0.84)明显减少,而围产儿死亡率(相对危险度0.99,95%可信区间0.82~1.19)并未增加。对于妊娠不足30周的胎儿进行研究得出同样的结论。对单纯从胎儿神经保护作用出发产前使用硫酸镁的4个研究(涉及胎儿4324名)进行分析,结果为母体产前使用硫酸镁可以减少脑瘫的发生。结论对于有早产风险的孕妇使用硫酸镁可以减少胎儿出生后脑瘫的发生率,而不会增加死胎的发生。
目的:繫統分析產前使用硫痠鎂對胎兒神經的保護作用。方法檢索 PubMed、Cochrane 圖書館、EMBASE、中國期刊全文數據庫、中國生物醫學文獻數據庫、中文科技期刊全文數據庫收錄的公開髮錶與研究目的相關的隨機對照研究文獻,對滿足條件的數據進行閤併分析,Meta 分析軟件用RevMan 5.0。評價指標包括:胎兒齣生後18~24箇月髮生腦癱併圍產兒死亡、腦癱、中-重度腦癱、中-重度腦癱併圍產兒死亡、圍產兒死亡,根據使用硫痠鎂時的妊娠週數來分析其對胎兒神經繫統的保護作用。結果5箇隨機對照研究(5235名胎兒/新生兒)納入分析。妊娠30~34週使用硫痠鎂併不能減少腦癱併圍產兒死亡的髮生率(相對危險度0.93,95%可信區間0.79~1.09),但是單獨髮生的腦癱(相對危險度0.70,95%可信區間0.54~0.90)、中-重度腦癱(相對危險度0.61,95%可信區間0.44~0.84)明顯減少,而圍產兒死亡率(相對危險度0.99,95%可信區間0.82~1.19)併未增加。對于妊娠不足30週的胎兒進行研究得齣同樣的結論。對單純從胎兒神經保護作用齣髮產前使用硫痠鎂的4箇研究(涉及胎兒4324名)進行分析,結果為母體產前使用硫痠鎂可以減少腦癱的髮生。結論對于有早產風險的孕婦使用硫痠鎂可以減少胎兒齣生後腦癱的髮生率,而不會增加死胎的髮生。
목적:계통분석산전사용류산미대태인신경적보호작용。방법검색 PubMed、Cochrane 도서관、EMBASE、중국기간전문수거고、중국생물의학문헌수거고、중문과기기간전문수거고수록적공개발표여연구목적상관적수궤대조연구문헌,대만족조건적수거진행합병분석,Meta 분석연건용RevMan 5.0。평개지표포괄:태인출생후18~24개월발생뇌탄병위산인사망、뇌탄、중-중도뇌탄、중-중도뇌탄병위산인사망、위산인사망,근거사용류산미시적임신주수래분석기대태인신경계통적보호작용。결과5개수궤대조연구(5235명태인/신생인)납입분석。임신30~34주사용류산미병불능감소뇌탄병위산인사망적발생솔(상대위험도0.93,95%가신구간0.79~1.09),단시단독발생적뇌탄(상대위험도0.70,95%가신구간0.54~0.90)、중-중도뇌탄(상대위험도0.61,95%가신구간0.44~0.84)명현감소,이위산인사망솔(상대위험도0.99,95%가신구간0.82~1.19)병미증가。대우임신불족30주적태인진행연구득출동양적결론。대단순종태인신경보호작용출발산전사용류산미적4개연구(섭급태인4324명)진행분석,결과위모체산전사용류산미가이감소뇌탄적발생。결론대우유조산풍험적잉부사용류산미가이감소태인출생후뇌탄적발생솔,이불회증가사태적발생。
Objective To review the evidence regarding neuroprotective effects of antenatal exposure to magnesium sulfate. Methods We conducted database searches of PubMed, Cochrane library, EMBASE, China Journal Full-text Database, Chinese Biomedical Database, Chinese Scientific Journals Full-text Database. Randomized controlled trials comparing Magnesium Sulfate with placebo/other treatment in patients at risk of preterm labor were evaluated for inclusion and methodological quality. The data was analyzed by RevMan 5.0. The outcomes were death with cerebral palsy by 18~24 months corrected age , death , cerebral palsy , moderate-severe cerebral palsy , and death with moderate-severe cerebral palsy. Result Five randomized controlled trials were included (5 235 fetuses/ infants). When analyzed by GA(gestational age) at randomization, in utero exposure to magnesium sulfate during 30~34 weeks did not reduce the rate of death or cerebral palsy (RR 0.93, 95%CI 0.79~1.09). However, cerebral palsy (RR 0.70, 95%CI 0.54~0.90), moderate-severe cerebral palsy (RR 0.61, 95%CI 0.44~0.84), and death with moderate-severe cerebral palsy were significantly reduced, without an evident increase in risk death (RR 0.99, 95%CI 0.82~1.19). Similar results were obtained when the GA at randomization was less than 30 weeks. When only neuroprotection trials (four trials, 4 324 fetuses/infants) are analyzed, in utero exposure to Magnesium Sulfate additionally reduced the outcome of cerebral palsy. Conclusion Fetal exposure to Magnesium Sulfate in women at risk of preterm delivery significantly reduces the risk of cerebral palsy without increasing the risk of death.