湖南工业大学学报（社会科学版）
湖南工業大學學報（社會科學版）
호남공업대학학보（사회과학판）
JOURNAL OF HUNAN UNIVERSITY OF TECHNOLOGY(SOCIAL SCIENCE EDITION)
2014年
1期
79-86
,共8页
嫖宿幼女罪%保留论%解释论%强奸罪%猥亵儿童罪
嫖宿幼女罪%保留論%解釋論%彊姦罪%猥褻兒童罪
표숙유녀죄%보류론%해석론%강간죄%외설인동죄
crime of prostituting girls under the age of 14%theory of reserving the crime%theory of interpretation%crime of rape%crime of child molestation
关于嫖宿幼女罪的论争，保留论者对嫖宿幼女罪合理性的论证理由不够充分，因为该罪名在立法目的、条文设置、司法实践与效益对比诸方面均存在缺陷，并且无法通过解释论进行解决。从短期来看，在没有相关司法解释或者立法修改时，司法上应该废弃嫖宿幼女罪的适用，将相关行为纳入相关犯罪条目进行规制；从长期着眼，应该坚持平等保护幼女合法权益的基本刑事政策，彻底废除嫖宿幼女罪罪名。
關于嫖宿幼女罪的論爭，保留論者對嫖宿幼女罪閤理性的論證理由不夠充分，因為該罪名在立法目的、條文設置、司法實踐與效益對比諸方麵均存在缺陷，併且無法通過解釋論進行解決。從短期來看，在沒有相關司法解釋或者立法脩改時，司法上應該廢棄嫖宿幼女罪的適用，將相關行為納入相關犯罪條目進行規製；從長期著眼，應該堅持平等保護幼女閤法權益的基本刑事政策，徹底廢除嫖宿幼女罪罪名。
관우표숙유녀죄적논쟁，보류론자대표숙유녀죄합이성적론증이유불구충분，인위해죄명재입법목적、조문설치、사법실천여효익대비제방면균존재결함，병차무법통과해석론진행해결。종단기래간，재몰유상관사법해석혹자입법수개시，사법상응해폐기표숙유녀죄적괄용，장상관행위납입상관범죄조목진행규제；종장기착안，응해견지평등보호유녀합법권익적기본형사정책，철저폐제표숙유녀죄죄명。
Those who are for reserving the crime of prostituting girls under the age of 14 don't give enough argu-ment.The crime has several defects in legislative purpose,provision's setting,juridical practice,benefit imbal-ance and etc.What's worse,these defects can't be settled by theory of interpretation.For the short term,the crime of prostituting girls under the age of 14 shall be ceased to apply in justice,and relative behaviors shall be regulated by means of being involved in relative crime until relative judicial interpretation or legislation amendment come out.For the long term,we should keep the basic criminal policies which equally protect the legal rights and benefits of girls under the age of 14,and abolish the crime of prostituting girls under the age of 14 completely.
