北方法学
北方法學
북방법학
NORTHERN LEGAL SCIENCE
2012年
3期
92-102
,共11页
阿列克西%水平效力%第三人效力%客观价值%客观原则
阿列剋西%水平效力%第三人效力%客觀價值%客觀原則
아렬극서%수평효력%제삼인효력%객관개치%객관원칙
Alexy%horizontal effect%third party effect%objective order of values%objective principle
阿列克西的宪法权利理论是有关公民宪法权利规范司法适用的理论,是有关公民之间宪法权利冲突与权衡的理论,因此该理论必然是有关宪法权利规范在公民之间进行司法适用的水平效力理论。因此,为使该理论能够成立,阿列克西一定要对其宪法权利规范水平效力的途径、内容、程度与合理性等问题进行理论上的建构。他的宪法权利规范水平效力建构的"三层次"说,是在德国的司法实践和学界的"客观价值辐射理论"和"三种模式"建构基础上所进行的整合与重构,具有很大的独特性、涵盖性与合理性。
阿列剋西的憲法權利理論是有關公民憲法權利規範司法適用的理論,是有關公民之間憲法權利遲突與權衡的理論,因此該理論必然是有關憲法權利規範在公民之間進行司法適用的水平效力理論。因此,為使該理論能夠成立,阿列剋西一定要對其憲法權利規範水平效力的途徑、內容、程度與閤理性等問題進行理論上的建構。他的憲法權利規範水平效力建構的"三層次"說,是在德國的司法實踐和學界的"客觀價值輻射理論"和"三種模式"建構基礎上所進行的整閤與重構,具有很大的獨特性、涵蓋性與閤理性。
아렬극서적헌법권리이론시유관공민헌법권리규범사법괄용적이론,시유관공민지간헌법권리충돌여권형적이론,인차해이론필연시유관헌법권리규범재공민지간진행사법괄용적수평효력이론。인차,위사해이론능구성립,아렬극서일정요대기헌법권리규범수평효력적도경、내용、정도여합이성등문제진행이론상적건구。타적헌법권리규범수평효력건구적"삼층차"설,시재덕국적사법실천화학계적"객관개치복사이론"화"삼충모식"건구기출상소진행적정합여중구,구유흔대적독특성、함개성여합이성。
Alexy' s theory of constitutional rights is a theory about judicial application of citizen' s constitutional right norms and conflict and balancing of constitutional rights between citizens. Hence it is inevitably to be a theory of horizontal effect of constitutional right norms. In order to make it tenable, Alexy has to construct his theory of horizontal effect of constitutional fight norms by explaining and establishing its path, content, extent and rationality. His three - stage model of horizontal effect is an integration and reconstruction of the concept of "an objective order of values" and "three models of construction" in Germany, thus it shows great creative spirit, rationality and more extensive applying character.