CAJ | 학술논문

量刑活动是否符合罪刑法定原则在司法上并非一个空洞的命题,其有着可操作的评价标准。这个标准既圈定了量刑与罪刑法定原则相契合的范围,也划定了量刑中的罪刑法定边界。基于罪刑法定的价值追求,在量刑中,罪刑法定的上限应止于具体法定刑幅度的最高刑;其下限则取决于由量刑情节所决定的实现罪刑相适应的需要。量刑中这样的罪刑法定边界,既是实现量刑合理与量刑合法有机统一的保障,也是规范量刑裁量权行使的藩篱与向导。
양형활동시부부합죄형법정원칙재사법상병비일개공동적명제,기유착가조작적평개표준。저개표준기권정료양형여죄형법정원칙상계합적범위,야화정료양형중적죄형법정변계。기우죄형법정적개치추구,재양형중,죄형법정적상한응지우구체법정형폭도적최고형;기하한칙취결우유양형정절소결정적실현죄형상괄응적수요。양형중저양적죄형법정변계,기시실현양형합리여양형합법유궤통일적보장,야시규범양형재량권행사적번리여향도。
Whether the sentence meets the principle of legality is of operational evaluation criteria,and therefore which is by no means an inane topic judicially.This criteria selected a scope corresponds to the sentence and the principle of legality,and delimited a boundary of legality in the sentence.Based on the value pursuit of the legality,the maximum limit of the principle of legality in the sentence should end in the maximum legally-prescribed punishment;while the minimum limit depends on the requirement of the balance between a crime and a punishment according to circumstances for sentencing.Such a boundary of legality in the sentence is not only the safeguard to realize the organic unification of the sentence justice and sentence legitimacy,but also the barrier and guide to regulate the measurement rights of the sentence.