北京行政学院学报
北京行政學院學報
북경행정학원학보
JOURNAL OF BEIJING ADMINISTRATIVE COLLEGE
2013年
6期
84-89
,共6页
概念行政法学%实证行政法学%行政处罚法
概唸行政法學%實證行政法學%行政處罰法
개념행정법학%실증행정법학%행정처벌법
conceptual administrative jurisprudence%empirical administrative jurisprudence%constitution of administrative illegal ac-tion%administrative penalties law
20世纪以来,缘于实证行政法学的冲击,公法学界开始有意冷落概念行政法学。但是,这并不是概念行政法学本身的缺陷所致,而是因为我们现在并不具有使用这一方法的能力。实际上,概念行政法学具有实证行政法学所欠缺的对价值的评估方法,而实证行政法学却存在着用对物体的认识手段研究“人”的根本错误,因而,概念行政法学理应得到重估和重用。譬如,将其运用在“应受行政处罚行为成立要件”主题上,我们便可获得一个逻辑闭合、体系严谨的理论框架。
20世紀以來,緣于實證行政法學的遲擊,公法學界開始有意冷落概唸行政法學。但是,這併不是概唸行政法學本身的缺陷所緻,而是因為我們現在併不具有使用這一方法的能力。實際上,概唸行政法學具有實證行政法學所欠缺的對價值的評估方法,而實證行政法學卻存在著用對物體的認識手段研究“人”的根本錯誤,因而,概唸行政法學理應得到重估和重用。譬如,將其運用在“應受行政處罰行為成立要件”主題上,我們便可穫得一箇邏輯閉閤、體繫嚴謹的理論框架。
20세기이래,연우실증행정법학적충격,공법학계개시유의랭락개념행정법학。단시,저병불시개념행정법학본신적결함소치,이시인위아문현재병불구유사용저일방법적능력。실제상,개념행정법학구유실증행정법학소흠결적대개치적평고방법,이실증행정법학각존재착용대물체적인식수단연구“인”적근본착오,인이,개념행정법학리응득도중고화중용。비여,장기운용재“응수행정처벌행위성립요건”주제상,아문편가획득일개라집폐합、체계엄근적이론광가。
Since the 20th century, due to the impact of empirical administrative jurisprudence, administrative law scholars began to leave out conceptual administrative jurisprudence intentionally, which isn’t due to intrinsic defects of conceptual administrative jurisprudence but scholars have no ability to use this method. In fact, conceptual administrative jurisprudence has a method to assess value that is lacking in empirical administrative jurisprudence while empirical administrative jurisprudence has a fundamental fault that it often applies some appraisal tools suitable form things to people. Therefore, conceptual administrative jurisprudence should be revaluated and reused. For example, if it can be applied to the research of constitution of administrative illegal action, we could obtain a theoretical framework with a closed logical and rigorous system.