集美大学学报:哲学社会科学版
集美大學學報:哲學社會科學版
집미대학학보:철학사회과학판
Journal of Jimei University (Philosophy and Social Sciences)
2012年
4期
102-107
,共6页
海峡两岸%行政命令%合法性审查
海峽兩岸%行政命令%閤法性審查
해협량안%행정명령%합법성심사
Taiwan and Mainland China%administrative order%legality examination
行政命令是行政行为法的重要组成部分。海峡两岸的行政法在各自发展的过程中,形成彼此联系又相异的特点。我国台湾地区行政命令体系比较完整,行政命令是与行政处分相对应的概念,属于抽象行政行为,大陆行政命令则学术界与实务相背离,在学术界往往理解为具体行政行为。合法性审查是行政命令法治化的重要手段,主要包括对行政命令发布主体权限的审查、行政命令内容合法性审查以及行政命令发布程序合法性审查等方面。两岸有着不同的行政命令合法性审查模式,在法理上台湾地区行政、立法、司法、考试及监察机关均可以审查行政命令的合法性,大陆行政命令应首先统一认识,并纳入抽象行政行为范畴,通过行政、立法、司法予以监督。
行政命令是行政行為法的重要組成部分。海峽兩岸的行政法在各自髮展的過程中,形成彼此聯繫又相異的特點。我國檯灣地區行政命令體繫比較完整,行政命令是與行政處分相對應的概唸,屬于抽象行政行為,大陸行政命令則學術界與實務相揹離,在學術界往往理解為具體行政行為。閤法性審查是行政命令法治化的重要手段,主要包括對行政命令髮佈主體權限的審查、行政命令內容閤法性審查以及行政命令髮佈程序閤法性審查等方麵。兩岸有著不同的行政命令閤法性審查模式,在法理上檯灣地區行政、立法、司法、攷試及鑑察機關均可以審查行政命令的閤法性,大陸行政命令應首先統一認識,併納入抽象行政行為範疇,通過行政、立法、司法予以鑑督。
행정명령시행정행위법적중요조성부분。해협량안적행정법재각자발전적과정중,형성피차련계우상이적특점。아국태만지구행정명령체계비교완정,행정명령시여행정처분상대응적개념,속우추상행정행위,대륙행정명령칙학술계여실무상배리,재학술계왕왕리해위구체행정행위。합법성심사시행정명령법치화적중요수단,주요포괄대행정명령발포주체권한적심사、행정명령내용합법성심사이급행정명령발포정서합법성심사등방면。량안유착불동적행정명령합법성심사모식,재법리상태만지구행정、입법、사법、고시급감찰궤관균가이심사행정명령적합법성,대륙행정명령응수선통일인식,병납입추상행정행위범주,통과행정、입법、사법여이감독。
Administrative order is an important part of administrative act of law. In their development, the administrative acts of law in Taiwan and Mainland China have formed their connection with each other in spite of their uniqueness. The law system in Taiwan is more complete. Administrative order there, a concept in contrast with administrative resolution, belongs to abstract ad ministrative action, whereas its counterpart in China Mainland is generally taken as concrete administrative action. Legality exam ination is a vital means to legalize administrative order. It accounts for the examination of the subject who gives the administrative order, the examination of the legality of the essence of the administrative order and the examination of the issuing process of the administrative order, etc. Taiwan and Mainland China have different models of legality examination of the administrative order. In Taiwan, the administration, legislation, justice and supervisory institution all have the right to examine the legality of administra tive order. Administrative order in Mainland China should be categorized in abstract administrative action, so that it can be su pervised by the administration, legislation and justice.