中华医学教育探索杂志
中華醫學教育探索雜誌
중화의학교육탐색잡지
Chinese Journal of Medical Education Research
2014年
2期
183-186,187
,共5页
刘军%吴忭%王敏红%金为民%王春刚
劉軍%吳忭%王敏紅%金為民%王春剛
류군%오변%왕민홍%금위민%왕춘강
图示工具%以问题为基础的学习%临床诊断%知能发展
圖示工具%以問題為基礎的學習%臨床診斷%知能髮展
도시공구%이문제위기출적학습%림상진단%지능발전
Visualization tool%Problem-based learning%Clinical diagnosis%Expertise development
目的:针对以问题为基础的学习(problem-based learning, PBL)中存在的学生难以系统建构医学知识体系以及难以将知识迁移用于解决新问题的挑战,利用图示工具支持的在线PBL系统,观察其对医学生临床诊断知识技能发展的影响。方法将52名学生平均分为实验组(采用有图示工具支持的在线PBL系统学习)和对照组(采用无图示工具支持的在线PBL系统学习)。学生按照学习系统中的要求,在线完成3个肾病临床病例的诊断分析,并就在线学习体验提供反馈意见。对2组学生的病例1和病例3的在线学习成绩分别采用配对t检验和单因素重复测量方差分析。结果结果显示,实验组有进步[病例1得分(1.47±0.54),病例3得分(2.14±0.55),P=0.015],而对照组无明显进步[病例1得分(1.57±0.67),病例3得分(1.66±0.49),P=0.234]。学生在线学习的前期(病例1)学习表现和组别因素对后期(病例3)学习表现具有交互作用影响(F=7.266, P=0.013)。结论初步表明图示工具支持的在线PBL学习系统能够有效促进医学生临床诊断知识技能发展。
目的:針對以問題為基礎的學習(problem-based learning, PBL)中存在的學生難以繫統建構醫學知識體繫以及難以將知識遷移用于解決新問題的挑戰,利用圖示工具支持的在線PBL繫統,觀察其對醫學生臨床診斷知識技能髮展的影響。方法將52名學生平均分為實驗組(採用有圖示工具支持的在線PBL繫統學習)和對照組(採用無圖示工具支持的在線PBL繫統學習)。學生按照學習繫統中的要求,在線完成3箇腎病臨床病例的診斷分析,併就在線學習體驗提供反饋意見。對2組學生的病例1和病例3的在線學習成績分彆採用配對t檢驗和單因素重複測量方差分析。結果結果顯示,實驗組有進步[病例1得分(1.47±0.54),病例3得分(2.14±0.55),P=0.015],而對照組無明顯進步[病例1得分(1.57±0.67),病例3得分(1.66±0.49),P=0.234]。學生在線學習的前期(病例1)學習錶現和組彆因素對後期(病例3)學習錶現具有交互作用影響(F=7.266, P=0.013)。結論初步錶明圖示工具支持的在線PBL學習繫統能夠有效促進醫學生臨床診斷知識技能髮展。
목적:침대이문제위기출적학습(problem-based learning, PBL)중존재적학생난이계통건구의학지식체계이급난이장지식천이용우해결신문제적도전,이용도시공구지지적재선PBL계통,관찰기대의학생림상진단지식기능발전적영향。방법장52명학생평균분위실험조(채용유도시공구지지적재선PBL계통학습)화대조조(채용무도시공구지지적재선PBL계통학습)。학생안조학습계통중적요구,재선완성3개신병림상병례적진단분석,병취재선학습체험제공반궤의견。대2조학생적병례1화병례3적재선학습성적분별채용배대t검험화단인소중복측량방차분석。결과결과현시,실험조유진보[병례1득분(1.47±0.54),병례3득분(2.14±0.55),P=0.015],이대조조무명현진보[병례1득분(1.57±0.67),병례3득분(1.66±0.49),P=0.234]。학생재선학습적전기(병례1)학습표현화조별인소대후기(병례3)학습표현구유교호작용영향(F=7.266, P=0.013)。결론초보표명도시공구지지적재선PBL학습계통능구유효촉진의학생림상진단지식기능발전。
Objective In problem-based learning, students are often found difficult to con-struct medical knowledge systematically and transfer knowledge to solve new problems. In face of this challenge, this study aims to investigate the effect of visualization tool-supported online problem-based learning on medical students' clinical diagnostic expertise development. Methods A controlled study was conducted and 52 medical students were randomly assigned into experimental group (using visual-ization tool-supported online PBL environment for learning) and control group (using online PBL envi-ronment for learning without visualization tool support). Participants were asked to complete the diag-nostic analysis of three kidney problems according to the requirements of the learning environments and to provide feedback of online learning experience afterwards. Paired-sample t test and one-way analysis of vonriance were used to analyze both group's case 1 and case 3 on line learing scores. Results The results revealed that the experimental group had significant improvement in online learning performance [case 1: (1.47 ±0.54), case 3: (2.14 ±0.55), P=0.015], while the control group had no significant improvement [case 1:(1.57±0.67), case 3:(1.66±0.49), P=0.234]. Early performance of online learning and group factor had interative effects (F=7.266, P=0.013). Conclusions The findings suggest that visualization tool-supported online PBL environment can facilitate medical student clinical diagnostic expertise development effectively.