护理学报
護理學報
호이학보
JOURNAL OF NURSING
2014年
14期
1-4
,共4页
王晓庆%段培蓓%张晓琴%诸建华
王曉慶%段培蓓%張曉琴%諸建華
왕효경%단배배%장효금%제건화
恶心呕吐,预期性%化疗%文献分析
噁心嘔吐,預期性%化療%文獻分析
악심구토,예기성%화료%문헌분석
anticipatory nausea and vomiting%chemotherapy,literature analysis
目的:分析我国肿瘤化疗患者预期性恶心呕吐干预性研究的现状,为今后的研究提供依据和方向。方法以“预期性恶心呕吐”、“胃肠道反应”、“化疗”为主题词,对中国期刊全文数据库(CNKI)、万方数据库、维普数据库(VIP)及中国生物医学数据库(CBM)关于肿瘤化疗患者预期性恶心呕吐研究的护理文献检索;采用EndNote X3软件查重,对符合纳入排除标准的文献采用改良后的Jadad量表进行方法学质量评价,采用 CONSORT声明2010版本对文献报告质量进行综合评价。结果共检索出10篇有关预期性恶心呕吐的干预性研究,干预方法涉及中医护理、心理干预及音乐疗法等。本次纳入的文献方法学质量极低, Jadad评分均低于2分,只有1项研究使用随机数字表进行随机分配,其他文献均只提及“随机”字样;无1篇采用分配隐藏、盲法及失访与退出的报道。纳入研究报告书写欠规范,主要体现在忽视随机方法的阐述、缺乏盲法、分配隐藏的使用、样本量无具体的估算方法、缺乏依从性、病例脱落及失访情况的分析及忽视不良反应的报告等。结论国内有关肿瘤化疗患者预期性恶心呕吐干预性研究较少;文献方法学质量较差,报告书写欠规范,因此,应加强预期性恶心呕吐干预性研究的方法学研究,注重报告的书写规范,以提高科研质量,满足循证需求。
目的:分析我國腫瘤化療患者預期性噁心嘔吐榦預性研究的現狀,為今後的研究提供依據和方嚮。方法以“預期性噁心嘔吐”、“胃腸道反應”、“化療”為主題詞,對中國期刊全文數據庫(CNKI)、萬方數據庫、維普數據庫(VIP)及中國生物醫學數據庫(CBM)關于腫瘤化療患者預期性噁心嘔吐研究的護理文獻檢索;採用EndNote X3軟件查重,對符閤納入排除標準的文獻採用改良後的Jadad量錶進行方法學質量評價,採用 CONSORT聲明2010版本對文獻報告質量進行綜閤評價。結果共檢索齣10篇有關預期性噁心嘔吐的榦預性研究,榦預方法涉及中醫護理、心理榦預及音樂療法等。本次納入的文獻方法學質量極低, Jadad評分均低于2分,隻有1項研究使用隨機數字錶進行隨機分配,其他文獻均隻提及“隨機”字樣;無1篇採用分配隱藏、盲法及失訪與退齣的報道。納入研究報告書寫欠規範,主要體現在忽視隨機方法的闡述、缺乏盲法、分配隱藏的使用、樣本量無具體的估算方法、缺乏依從性、病例脫落及失訪情況的分析及忽視不良反應的報告等。結論國內有關腫瘤化療患者預期性噁心嘔吐榦預性研究較少;文獻方法學質量較差,報告書寫欠規範,因此,應加彊預期性噁心嘔吐榦預性研究的方法學研究,註重報告的書寫規範,以提高科研質量,滿足循證需求。
목적:분석아국종류화료환자예기성악심구토간예성연구적현상,위금후적연구제공의거화방향。방법이“예기성악심구토”、“위장도반응”、“화료”위주제사,대중국기간전문수거고(CNKI)、만방수거고、유보수거고(VIP)급중국생물의학수거고(CBM)관우종류화료환자예기성악심구토연구적호리문헌검색;채용EndNote X3연건사중,대부합납입배제표준적문헌채용개량후적Jadad량표진행방법학질량평개,채용 CONSORT성명2010판본대문헌보고질량진행종합평개。결과공검색출10편유관예기성악심구토적간예성연구,간예방법섭급중의호리、심리간예급음악요법등。본차납입적문헌방법학질량겁저, Jadad평분균저우2분,지유1항연구사용수궤수자표진행수궤분배,기타문헌균지제급“수궤”자양;무1편채용분배은장、맹법급실방여퇴출적보도。납입연구보고서사흠규범,주요체현재홀시수궤방법적천술、결핍맹법、분배은장적사용、양본량무구체적고산방법、결핍의종성、병례탈락급실방정황적분석급홀시불량반응적보고등。결론국내유관종류화료환자예기성악심구토간예성연구교소;문헌방법학질량교차,보고서사흠규범,인차,응가강예기성악심구토간예성연구적방법학연구,주중보고적서사규범,이제고과연질량,만족순증수구。
Objective To analyze the current intervention studies on anticipatory nausea and vomiting for cancer patients with chemotherapy and to provide reference for its future studies in China. Methods Literature review with anticipatory nausea and vomiting, gastrointestinal reaction and chemotherapy as key words was conducted in CNKI, Wanfang Data, VIP and CBM and EndNote X3 was applied for duplicate checking, improved Jadad score for methodological quality assessment for those included then comprehensive assessment of the literatures was formed through The CONSORT (Consolidated Standards of Reporting Trials) 2010 Statement. Results Ten literatures were included and interventions mentioned in the literatures involved TCM nursing, psychological intervention and music therapy. Average Jadad score of the literatures was less than two, which indicated poor quality of the literatures. Random number table was found in only one literature and no literature reporting the results with allocation concealment, blinding and withdraw/lost follow-up was found and all literatures lacked standardized writing. Conclusion With poor methodology quality and non-standardized writing, there are less intervention studies on anticipatory nausea and vomiting for cancer patients with chemotherapy in China. Methodology studies on anticipatory nausea and vomiting are in urgent need and more attention should be paid to standardized writing.