听力学及言语疾病杂志
聽力學及言語疾病雜誌
은역학급언어질병잡지
JOURNAL OF AUDIOLOGY AND SPEECH PATHOLOGY
2014年
5期
485-488
,共4页
谢华顺%马芙蓉%樊东升%王丽平%闫燕%鹿培泉
謝華順%馬芙蓉%樊東升%王麗平%閆燕%鹿培泉
사화순%마부용%번동승%왕려평%염연%록배천
肌萎缩侧索硬化症%喉肌电图%吞咽障碍%洼田饮水试验
肌萎縮側索硬化癥%喉肌電圖%吞嚥障礙%窪田飲水試驗
기위축측색경화증%후기전도%탄인장애%와전음수시험
Amyotrophic lateral sclerosis%Laryngeal electromyography%Swallowing disorders%Kubota drinking test
目的:探讨环甲肌肌电图用于评估肌萎缩侧索硬化症患者吞咽障碍的可行性。方法对25例伴或不伴吞咽异常的肌萎缩侧索硬化症患者行右侧环甲肌肌电图检查,并通过洼田饮水实验对吞咽功能进行评估,比较两种检查结果。结果25例中,11例环甲肌肌电图表现为典型的失神经支配,15例洼田饮水实验阳性,两种方法符合率为60%(15/25),其中阳性符合率为32%(8/25)。McNemar检验验证喉肌电图检查和洼田饮水试验的一致性,Kappa系数为0.219(P=0.344)。结论环甲肌肌电图可用于评估肌萎缩侧索硬化症患者的吞咽功能,但存在一定的局限性。
目的:探討環甲肌肌電圖用于評估肌萎縮側索硬化癥患者吞嚥障礙的可行性。方法對25例伴或不伴吞嚥異常的肌萎縮側索硬化癥患者行右側環甲肌肌電圖檢查,併通過窪田飲水實驗對吞嚥功能進行評估,比較兩種檢查結果。結果25例中,11例環甲肌肌電圖錶現為典型的失神經支配,15例窪田飲水實驗暘性,兩種方法符閤率為60%(15/25),其中暘性符閤率為32%(8/25)。McNemar檢驗驗證喉肌電圖檢查和窪田飲水試驗的一緻性,Kappa繫數為0.219(P=0.344)。結論環甲肌肌電圖可用于評估肌萎縮側索硬化癥患者的吞嚥功能,但存在一定的跼限性。
목적:탐토배갑기기전도용우평고기위축측색경화증환자탄인장애적가행성。방법대25례반혹불반탄인이상적기위축측색경화증환자행우측배갑기기전도검사,병통과와전음수실험대탄인공능진행평고,비교량충검사결과。결과25례중,11례배갑기기전도표현위전형적실신경지배,15례와전음수실험양성,량충방법부합솔위60%(15/25),기중양성부합솔위32%(8/25)。McNemar검험험증후기전도검사화와전음수시험적일치성,Kappa계수위0.219(P=0.344)。결론배갑기기전도가용우평고기위축측색경화증환자적탄인공능,단존재일정적국한성。
Objective To investigate the clinical values of laryngeal electromyography (LEMG) for evaluating the amyotrophic lateral sclerosis(ALS) patients with swallowing disorder .Methods A total of 25 ALS patients with or without complaining of swallowing disorder were recruited for the study .Their right cricothyroid muscles were taken unilaterally with concentric needle electrodes by anterior cervical approach .Each patient was tested with Kub-ota drinking test too .Results Of all the 25 patients ,11 were found abnormal in the right cricothyroid muscle which presented with typical degeneration patterns ,15 cases were found abnormal by Kubota drinking test .The coinci-dence rate of the two methods was 60% ,the poisitive coincidence rate was 32% .The McNemar test showed there was some consistency between the drinking water test and LEMG (P=0 .344) ,and the Kappa coefficient was 0 .219 . Conclusion The cricothyroid muscle electromyography may also be a potential method to evaluate ALS patients since it seemed to offer an evidence of dysphagia related with abnormal sensory function of laryngeal mucosa .But there may be some limitations .