浙江医学教育
浙江醫學教育
절강의학교육
Zhejiang Medical Education
2014年
5期
24-26
,共3页
幽门螺杆菌%根除率%经济成本
幽門螺桿菌%根除率%經濟成本
유문라간균%근제솔%경제성본
Helicobacter Pylori%eradication rate%economic cost
目的:研究3种不同药物方案治疗幽门螺杆菌(Helicobacter Pylor ,HP)的根除疗效及经济成本。方法:180例HP患者随机分成A、B、C 3组,A组给以替那拉唑10mg+阿莫西林1000mg+克拉霉素500mg;B组给以兰索拉唑10mg+呋喃西林100mg+卡那霉素500mg;C组给以胶体果胶铋200mg+培氟沙星200mg+羧苄西林1000mg;3组均口服,2次/日,疗程均为7天。治疗4周后胃镜复查和14 C呼气试验,比较根除率,并对成本效果比(C/E )和增量成本-效果比(△C/△E )分析。结果:ITT分析和PP分析根除率,发现C组与A、B组相比较差异有统计学意义( P<0.05);ITT和PP分析C/E ,证明C组所需成本最低,且相对于A组,C组△C/△E较B组低,表明在同等疗效前提下所需的成本较小。结论:胶体果胶铋、培氟沙星、羧苄西林药物联用疗法更符合理想的HP根除方案要求,高效、安全、经济,适用于临床应用。
目的:研究3種不同藥物方案治療幽門螺桿菌(Helicobacter Pylor ,HP)的根除療效及經濟成本。方法:180例HP患者隨機分成A、B、C 3組,A組給以替那拉唑10mg+阿莫西林1000mg+剋拉黴素500mg;B組給以蘭索拉唑10mg+呋喃西林100mg+卡那黴素500mg;C組給以膠體果膠鉍200mg+培氟沙星200mg+羧芐西林1000mg;3組均口服,2次/日,療程均為7天。治療4週後胃鏡複查和14 C呼氣試驗,比較根除率,併對成本效果比(C/E )和增量成本-效果比(△C/△E )分析。結果:ITT分析和PP分析根除率,髮現C組與A、B組相比較差異有統計學意義( P<0.05);ITT和PP分析C/E ,證明C組所需成本最低,且相對于A組,C組△C/△E較B組低,錶明在同等療效前提下所需的成本較小。結論:膠體果膠鉍、培氟沙星、羧芐西林藥物聯用療法更符閤理想的HP根除方案要求,高效、安全、經濟,適用于臨床應用。
목적:연구3충불동약물방안치료유문라간균(Helicobacter Pylor ,HP)적근제료효급경제성본。방법:180례HP환자수궤분성A、B、C 3조,A조급이체나랍서10mg+아막서림1000mg+극랍매소500mg;B조급이란색랍서10mg+부남서림100mg+잡나매소500mg;C조급이효체과효필200mg+배불사성200mg+최변서림1000mg;3조균구복,2차/일,료정균위7천。치료4주후위경복사화14 C호기시험,비교근제솔,병대성본효과비(C/E )화증량성본-효과비(△C/△E )분석。결과:ITT분석화PP분석근제솔,발현C조여A、B조상비교차이유통계학의의( P<0.05);ITT화PP분석C/E ,증명C조소수성본최저,차상대우A조,C조△C/△E교B조저,표명재동등료효전제하소수적성본교소。결론:효체과효필、배불사성、최변서림약물련용요법경부합이상적HP근제방안요구,고효、안전、경제,괄용우림상응용。
Objective]To study the clinical efficacy and economic cost of three drug treatment projects ofhelicobacter pylori (HP) eradication .[Method]One hundred and eighty HP patients were randomly divided into three groups ,group A ,group B and group C .10 mg tenprazole and 1000 mg amoxicillin (Huameihua , Wuhan ) and 500 mg clarithromycin were applied in group A ,10 mg lansoprazole and 100 mg furacilin and 500 mg kanamycin were applied in group B ,200 mg colloidal bismuth pectin and 200 mg pefloxacin and 1000 mg carbenicillin were applied in group C ,which were took via orally twice a day and all the times of therapy were 7 days;Stomachoscopy gastroscopy and 14C-urea breath test were applied to compare the elimina-tion rate 4 weeks after drug treatment .C/E and△C/△E were evaluated .[Result]Eradication rates analyzed by ITTand PP demonstrated group C were obviously higher than groups A and B ( P<0.05 ) .C/E revealed by ITT and PP demonstrated the cost of group C was lowest .The smaller value of △C/△E in group C suggested a lower cost under the precondition achieving equivalent efficacy ,using the group A as control .[Conclusion ]Combination of colloidal bismuth pectin , pefloxacin and car-benicillin was more suitable as the ideal project on HP eradication in clinical ,which was proved to be effective ,safe and eco-nomical .