上海公安高等专科学校学报(公安理论与实践)
上海公安高等專科學校學報(公安理論與實踐)
상해공안고등전과학교학보(공안이론여실천)
JOURNAL OF SHANGHAI PUBLIC SECURITY ACADEMY
2014年
5期
76-80
,共5页
非典型%虐待%刑法%规制
非典型%虐待%刑法%規製
비전형%학대%형법%규제
Atypical%Abuse%Criminal Law%Curb
发生在幼儿园、养老院、社会救助站等监管机构的非典型虐待行为与发生在家庭成员之间的虐待行为一样,具有严重的社会危害性,需要受到刑法的规制。两类虐待行为主体之间的关系看似不同,实则有着本质上的趋同性--都是一种十分紧密的社会关系,有较为明确的强势方和弱势方。但是,现行刑法对虐待罪的犯罪主体范围规定得过于狭窄,刑法中的其他相关罪名也不能完全涵盖需要科处刑罚的非典型虐待行为,只有通过修改法律扩大虐待罪的主体范围,才能使非典型虐待行为得到刑法的全面规制。
髮生在幼兒園、養老院、社會救助站等鑑管機構的非典型虐待行為與髮生在傢庭成員之間的虐待行為一樣,具有嚴重的社會危害性,需要受到刑法的規製。兩類虐待行為主體之間的關繫看似不同,實則有著本質上的趨同性--都是一種十分緊密的社會關繫,有較為明確的彊勢方和弱勢方。但是,現行刑法對虐待罪的犯罪主體範圍規定得過于狹窄,刑法中的其他相關罪名也不能完全涵蓋需要科處刑罰的非典型虐待行為,隻有通過脩改法律擴大虐待罪的主體範圍,纔能使非典型虐待行為得到刑法的全麵規製。
발생재유인완、양로원、사회구조참등감관궤구적비전형학대행위여발생재가정성원지간적학대행위일양,구유엄중적사회위해성,수요수도형법적규제。량류학대행위주체지간적관계간사불동,실칙유착본질상적추동성--도시일충십분긴밀적사회관계,유교위명학적강세방화약세방。단시,현행형법대학대죄적범죄주체범위규정득과우협착,형법중적기타상관죄명야불능완전함개수요과처형벌적비전형학대행위,지유통과수개법률확대학대죄적주체범위,재능사비전형학대행위득도형법적전면규제。
Abuses that take place in orphanages, nursing homes and such regulatory institutions as relief stations are similar to those that take place between family members, both kinds of which have bad effects on society and should be curbed by the criminal law. The subjects of two kinds of abuses appear different but similar in nature:Both have close social relationship and one party is strong and the other is weak. But the present criminal law has too narrow deifnition for the actors of the abuses and related crimes can not include all atypical abuses which require penalty. Only by amending the law and expanding the range of the crime can the atypical abuses be generally curbed.