CAJ | 학술논문

《儒将张俊》是一部乡土史学新著，涉及湘军和甘军平定西北叛乱诸问题，提供了不少新史料和新见解，但主导观点仍然沿袭着民国暨新中国以来的正统看法，认为左宗棠、刘锦堂、董福祥、张俊等平定陕甘回民起义有罪。其实有大量史实证明这种一向政治正确兼学术正确的正统观点有误，应该有所反思，因为它既不合历史的实际，也不合中华民族大家庭的共同利益。
《유장장준》시일부향토사학신저，섭급상군화감군평정서북반란제문제，제공료불소신사료화신견해，단주도관점잉연연습착민국기신중국이래적정통간법，인위좌종당、류금당、동복상、장준등평정협감회민기의유죄。기실유대량사실증명저충일향정치정학겸학술정학적정통관점유오，응해유소반사，인위타기불합역사적실제，야불합중화민족대가정적공동이익。
A Ref ined General of Zhangjun is a new historical book ,involving pacifying northwest re-bellion by the armies from Hunan and Gansu .Although it provides a lot of new materials and new insights , the dominant views still carry on the orthodox views of thinking Zuo zongtang ,Liu Jintang ,Dong Fuhsiang and Zhangjun were guilty in pacifying the uprising of Hui-nationality in Shanxi and Gansu .However there are a large number of facts prove that this idea w hich seems politically correct and academically right is ac-tually wrong .It's worthy being reflected because it was neither loyal to the actual history ,nor to the com-mon interests of Chinese nations .