湖北职业技术学院学报
湖北職業技術學院學報
호북직업기술학원학보
JOURNAL OF XIAOGAN VOCATIONAL-TECHNICAL COLLEGE
2014年
3期
71-75
,共5页
死刑复核%辩护权%监狱侦查%不当辩护
死刑複覈%辯護權%鑑獄偵查%不噹辯護
사형복핵%변호권%감옥정사%불당변호
the death sentence review%the right to defence%jail investigation%mispleading
死刑复核程序中,被追诉人的辩护权受到立法保护,为了落实辩护权,需要保障辩护律师有效辩护。然而,辩护律师与非羁押当事人的会见可以被合法监控;辩护律师可以向死刑复核的法官提交辩护意见,但面临操作的困难;辩护律师可以间接推导案件进展,但需要设立具体流程供辩护律师向承办法官提交意见。死缓罪犯故意犯罪案件由监狱侦查,但立法空缺、执法可能不当将使得辩护权难以得到保障。上述问题可以从立法和司法实践两个方面予以改进。在推进辩护律师有效辩护的同时,还要发挥检察机关的作用防范不当辩护。
死刑複覈程序中,被追訴人的辯護權受到立法保護,為瞭落實辯護權,需要保障辯護律師有效辯護。然而,辯護律師與非羈押噹事人的會見可以被閤法鑑控;辯護律師可以嚮死刑複覈的法官提交辯護意見,但麵臨操作的睏難;辯護律師可以間接推導案件進展,但需要設立具體流程供辯護律師嚮承辦法官提交意見。死緩罪犯故意犯罪案件由鑑獄偵查,但立法空缺、執法可能不噹將使得辯護權難以得到保障。上述問題可以從立法和司法實踐兩箇方麵予以改進。在推進辯護律師有效辯護的同時,還要髮揮檢察機關的作用防範不噹辯護。
사형복핵정서중,피추소인적변호권수도입법보호,위료락실변호권,수요보장변호률사유효변호。연이,변호률사여비기압당사인적회견가이피합법감공;변호률사가이향사형복핵적법관제교변호의견,단면림조작적곤난;변호률사가이간접추도안건진전,단수요설립구체류정공변호률사향승판법관제교의견。사완죄범고의범죄안건유감옥정사,단입법공결、집법가능불당장사득변호권난이득도보장。상술문제가이종입법화사법실천량개방면여이개진。재추진변호률사유효변호적동시,환요발휘검찰궤관적작용방범불당변호。
In the death sentence review process , the defending right of the accused is protected by legislation . But to enhance the defending right , the effective defense of the defending attorney should be protected .However , the meeting between the defending attorney and the client who is not in custody may be scrutinized legally .The de-fending attorney has the right to deliver the defending opinion to the judge in charge of the death sentence review , but there are operation difficulties .The defending attorney may induce the case process indirectly , but we should set guidelines for the defending attorney to deliver opinions to the judge in charge .The jail investigates the crime allegedly to be deliberately conducted by the guilty who has been sentenced to death sentence with a reprieve .The lack of relevant legislation and improper enforcement hamper the effective defense .We may reform from the two as-pects of legislation and judicial practice .While advancing the effective defense , we should also prevent misplead-ing.