CAJ | 학술논문

学术界对作为政治文化研究主要方法的经验方法的批评文章从概念的视角对其进行了引述和分析.指出,如果一个理论没有解决内部的概念问题,它就可能自相矛盾或使解释机制模糊不清;如果没有解决外部的概念问题,就可能忽视与它相关的研究传统的基本的认知和概念借用及创新.政治文化研究所使用的主观性文化概念,从政治文化、社会资本到价值观是有所进步的,但仍难以观察或确定,从而使它无法摆脱对经验性研究方法的依赖.把这些概念应用到政治文化研究中,难以提供令人信服的因果关系或其他确定性的解释,它们在如何激励个体行动、在聚合人们行为时是如何保持连续性或发生变化的问题上也存在着局限性,因此概念构建是不可避免的.
학술계대작위정치문화연구주요방법적경험방법적비평문장종개념적시각대기진행료인술화분석.지출,여과일개이론몰유해결내부적개념문제,타취가능자상모순혹사해석궤제모호불청;여과몰유해결외부적개념문제,취가능홀시여타상관적연구전통적기본적인지화개념차용급창신.정치문화연구소사용적주관성문화개념,종정치문화、사회자본도개치관시유소진보적,단잉난이관찰혹학정,종이사타무법파탈대경험성연구방법적의뢰.파저사개념응용도정치문화연구중,난이제공령인신복적인과관계혹기타학정성적해석,타문재여하격려개체행동、재취합인문행위시시여하보지련속성혹발생변화적문제상야존재착국한성,인차개념구건시불가피면적.
The critical papers on the empirical method as a major method in the study of political culture are quoted and an￣alyzed from the conceptual perspective. The conceptual dilemma either causes contradictions in the theory itself and ambiguity in its interpretation mechanism,or negligence of the basic understanding of the related research traditions,and borrowings and inno￣vation of concepts. Some subjective cultural concepts in the study of political culture,such as political culture,social capital and value,are progressive,but they are still difficult to be observed or determined. As a result,the study of political culture can not be free from dependence on the empirical research method. Although these concepts are applied to the study of political culture,it is impossible to make convincing explanations on causal relationship or make definitive explanation. There are some limitations in those concepts in terms of how to motivate individual and how to keep continuity or change in the aggregation of human behavior. Therefore,the conceptual construction is inevitable and essential.