乌鲁木齐职业大学学报
烏魯木齊職業大學學報
오로목제직업대학학보
JOURNAL OF URUMQI VOCATIONAL UNIVERSITY
2012年
4期
7-11
,共5页
聂绀弩%顾随%石头记%抄本%红学
聶紺弩%顧隨%石頭記%抄本%紅學
섭감노%고수%석두기%초본%홍학
NIE Gan-nu%GU Sui%Stone Tale%hand-copied book%the study of A Dream of Red Mansions
所谓《赠周汝昌》“谁知历史有曹宣”一诗的作者是聂绀弩,所谓顾随《木兰花慢》(石头非宝玉)一词的标题是“再题玉言新证”,这都是未见可靠凭据的,因而是难以采信的.天津王超现藏《石头记》抄本,它的祖本是否“乾隆庚寅年抄本”,它的原件是否“清代抄本”,目前均应存疑.
所謂《贈週汝昌》“誰知歷史有曹宣”一詩的作者是聶紺弩,所謂顧隨《木蘭花慢》(石頭非寶玉)一詞的標題是“再題玉言新證”,這都是未見可靠憑據的,因而是難以採信的.天津王超現藏《石頭記》抄本,它的祖本是否“乾隆庚寅年抄本”,它的原件是否“清代抄本”,目前均應存疑.
소위《증주여창》“수지역사유조선”일시적작자시섭감노,소위고수《목란화만》(석두비보옥)일사적표제시“재제옥언신증”,저도시미견가고빙거적,인이시난이채신적.천진왕초현장《석두기》초본,타적조본시부“건륭경인년초본”,타적원건시부“청대초본”,목전균응존의.
Somebody argued that the author of the poem “Who knows CAO Xuan in History” in the book To ZHOU RU-chang was NIE Gan-nu and that the title of the“Slow Song of Magnolia Flower”written by GU Sui was“New Proof of Rewritten Speech”, which lack evidence and such statements can not be convinced. For the hand-copied book Stone Tale collected by WANG Chao in Tianjin, someone declared that its original was the“copied book in 1770”, which is also doubtful.