中华行为医学与脑科学杂志
中華行為醫學與腦科學雜誌
중화행위의학여뇌과학잡지
CHINESE JOURNAL OF BEHAVIORAL MEDICINE AND BRAIN SCIENCE
2014年
12期
1087-1089
,共3页
张保华%谭云龙%王志仁%张五芳%杨甫德%卞清涛%韩笑乐%江述荣%杨贵刚
張保華%譚雲龍%王誌仁%張五芳%楊甫德%卞清濤%韓笑樂%江述榮%楊貴剛
장보화%담운룡%왕지인%장오방%양보덕%변청도%한소악%강술영%양귀강
重复经颅磁刺激%精神分裂症%迟发性运动障碍%疗效
重複經顱磁刺激%精神分裂癥%遲髮性運動障礙%療效
중복경로자자격%정신분렬증%지발성운동장애%료효
Repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS)%Schizophrenia%Tardive dyskinesia (TD)%Efficacy
目的 探讨不同频率重复经颅磁刺激(rTMS)治疗迟发性运动障碍(TD)的疗效.方法 长期服用抗精神病药所致迟发性运动障碍的精神分裂症患者,随机给予1 Hz(低频)和10 Hz(高频)的rTMS治疗4周,每周治疗5d.中间休息2周.分别在治疗前和治疗后进行异常不自主运动评定量表(AIMS)和锥体外系副反应量表(RESES)评定,评分变化作为疗效和副反应评价指标.结果 低频组经rTMS治疗后只有上肢的不自主运动改善[治疗前(2.6±1.0)分,治疗后(1.8±1.1)分],差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).高频组经rTMS治疗后多个量表分下降,其中上肢[治疗前(1.9±1.2)分,治疗后(0.8±0.9)分]、唇及口周[治疗前(1.0±0.8)分,治疗后(0.3±0.5)分]和舌[治疗前(2.6±0.9)分,治疗后(1.7±0.9)分]及总量表分[治疗前(7.7±3.0)分,治疗后(4.2±1.7)分]评分治疗前后差异有统计学意义(P< 0.05或<0.01).另外,两组间在下肢和总量表分减分率方面差异有统计学意义(P<0.05).结论 rTMS治疗TD有效,且高频(10 Hz)组治疗TD效果好.
目的 探討不同頻率重複經顱磁刺激(rTMS)治療遲髮性運動障礙(TD)的療效.方法 長期服用抗精神病藥所緻遲髮性運動障礙的精神分裂癥患者,隨機給予1 Hz(低頻)和10 Hz(高頻)的rTMS治療4週,每週治療5d.中間休息2週.分彆在治療前和治療後進行異常不自主運動評定量錶(AIMS)和錐體外繫副反應量錶(RESES)評定,評分變化作為療效和副反應評價指標.結果 低頻組經rTMS治療後隻有上肢的不自主運動改善[治療前(2.6±1.0)分,治療後(1.8±1.1)分],差異有統計學意義(P<0.05).高頻組經rTMS治療後多箇量錶分下降,其中上肢[治療前(1.9±1.2)分,治療後(0.8±0.9)分]、脣及口週[治療前(1.0±0.8)分,治療後(0.3±0.5)分]和舌[治療前(2.6±0.9)分,治療後(1.7±0.9)分]及總量錶分[治療前(7.7±3.0)分,治療後(4.2±1.7)分]評分治療前後差異有統計學意義(P< 0.05或<0.01).另外,兩組間在下肢和總量錶分減分率方麵差異有統計學意義(P<0.05).結論 rTMS治療TD有效,且高頻(10 Hz)組治療TD效果好.
목적 탐토불동빈솔중복경로자자격(rTMS)치료지발성운동장애(TD)적료효.방법 장기복용항정신병약소치지발성운동장애적정신분렬증환자,수궤급여1 Hz(저빈)화10 Hz(고빈)적rTMS치료4주,매주치료5d.중간휴식2주.분별재치료전화치료후진행이상불자주운동평정량표(AIMS)화추체외계부반응량표(RESES)평정,평분변화작위료효화부반응평개지표.결과 저빈조경rTMS치료후지유상지적불자주운동개선[치료전(2.6±1.0)분,치료후(1.8±1.1)분],차이유통계학의의(P<0.05).고빈조경rTMS치료후다개량표분하강,기중상지[치료전(1.9±1.2)분,치료후(0.8±0.9)분]、진급구주[치료전(1.0±0.8)분,치료후(0.3±0.5)분]화설[치료전(2.6±0.9)분,치료후(1.7±0.9)분]급총량표분[치료전(7.7±3.0)분,치료후(4.2±1.7)분]평분치료전후차이유통계학의의(P< 0.05혹<0.01).령외,량조간재하지화총량표분감분솔방면차이유통계학의의(P<0.05).결론 rTMS치료TD유효,차고빈(10 Hz)조치료TD효과호.
Objective To investigate the effect of different frequency of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation (rTMS)on tardive dyskinesia (TD).Methods Schizophrenia combined with antipsychotic-induced TD were screened.All patients were planed to receive 1Hz or 10Hz rTMS for 4 weeks in which two weeks' break was inserted at end of 2nd weekend.The curative effect and side effects were assessed by abnormal involuntary movement scale(AIMS) and rating scale for extrapyramidal side effects(RSESE) respectively at before and after treatment.Results In the 1Hz group,only Involuntary movements of the upper extremities were improved after rTMS treatment (before treatment 2.6± 1.0,after treatment 1.8 ± 1.1),the difference was statistically significant (P<0.05).But in 10Hz group,upper extremities (before treatment 1.9 ± 1.2,0.8 ± 0.9 after treatment),mouth (before treatment 1.0±0.8,after treatment 0.3±0.5),tongue(before treatment 2.6±0.9,after treatment 1.7±0.9),and total score(before treatment 7.7±3.0,after treatment 4.2±1.7) significantly decreased after rTMS treatment(P<0.05 or <0.01).In addition,the reduction rates in both the lower extremities and the total score was statistically different between the two groups (P<0.05).Conclusion rTMS can reduce the symptom of involuntary movement of TD patients and 10Hz rTMS is better.