医学与哲学
醫學與哲學
의학여철학
MEDICINE AND PHILOSOPHY
2015年
1期
10-13,54
,共5页
科学引文索引%SCI崇拜%文化自信
科學引文索引%SCI崇拜%文化自信
과학인문색인%SCI숭배%문화자신
science citation index%worship of science citation index%cultural confidence
阐述了当前中国学术界SCI崇拜的情绪已经蔓延和传导到了SCI源期刊本身,以及人文和社会科学领域;同时指出要辩证看待SCI的功用,客观合理地使用这种评价工具,不能泛化,也不能异化;不能妖魔化,也不能神化。分析了SCI崇拜产生的历史原因是文化失落、现实原因是政府评价、直接原因是人才评价,指出告别SCI崇拜,需要在复兴传统文化的过程中重塑文化自信,需要立足教学、科研、医疗等不同性质岗位的实际变革评价制度。
闡述瞭噹前中國學術界SCI崇拜的情緒已經蔓延和傳導到瞭SCI源期刊本身,以及人文和社會科學領域;同時指齣要辯證看待SCI的功用,客觀閤理地使用這種評價工具,不能汎化,也不能異化;不能妖魔化,也不能神化。分析瞭SCI崇拜產生的歷史原因是文化失落、現實原因是政府評價、直接原因是人纔評價,指齣告彆SCI崇拜,需要在複興傳統文化的過程中重塑文化自信,需要立足教學、科研、醫療等不同性質崗位的實際變革評價製度。
천술료당전중국학술계SCI숭배적정서이경만연화전도도료SCI원기간본신,이급인문화사회과학영역;동시지출요변증간대SCI적공용,객관합리지사용저충평개공구,불능범화,야불능이화;불능요마화,야불능신화。분석료SCI숭배산생적역사원인시문화실락、현실원인시정부평개、직접원인시인재평개,지출고별SCI숭배,수요재복흥전통문화적과정중중소문화자신,수요립족교학、과연、의료등불동성질강위적실제변혁평개제도。
The worship of science citation index (SCI) has not only dominated the SCI source journals ,but also spreaded to the field of humanities and social sciences in the academic community of China currently .A dialectical view of SCI function is needed .And we should use SCI as evaluation criteria objectively and reasonably .In addition ,SCI is not the only method and a non‐biased evaluation of SCI should be encouraged .This paper analyzed the historical reason for SCI worship that was the loss of traditional culture ,and the realistic reason was the government evaluation ,and the direct reason was the talent evaluation criteria .If say goodbye to the worship of SCI ,we should rebuild the cultural confidence in the process of the revival of traditional culture .Furthermore ,the evaluation system should be modified and changed based on different positions ,including teaching ,scientific research as well as clinical practice .