证据科学
證據科學
증거과학
EVIDENCE SEIENCE
2014年
6期
698-715
,共18页
专家辅助人%专门知识%司法鉴定%鉴定意见%专家
專傢輔助人%專門知識%司法鑒定%鑒定意見%專傢
전가보조인%전문지식%사법감정%감정의견%전가
Assistant expert%Specialized knowledge%Judicial appraisal%Appraisal opinion%Expert
专家辅助人制度是近年来我国诉讼法确立的一项新制度,无论在理论研究层面,还是在立法层面,乃至实践操作层面,专家辅助人资格的认定标准和认定程序都存在不足。在域外,存在与我国专家辅助人相似的一些制度,比如英美法系的专家证人制度、美国的法院之友、英国的技术陪审员、意大利的技术顾问、日本的诉讼辅佐人制度等,这些国家在规定这些制度时都对专家的资格审查、认定设立了相应的标准和程序。笔者在借鉴域外相关国家和地区法律规定的同时,结合中国现实国情,从专家辅助人的资格认定标准、资格审查程序以及其他辅助性制度等三方面提出建议。
專傢輔助人製度是近年來我國訴訟法確立的一項新製度,無論在理論研究層麵,還是在立法層麵,迺至實踐操作層麵,專傢輔助人資格的認定標準和認定程序都存在不足。在域外,存在與我國專傢輔助人相似的一些製度,比如英美法繫的專傢證人製度、美國的法院之友、英國的技術陪審員、意大利的技術顧問、日本的訴訟輔佐人製度等,這些國傢在規定這些製度時都對專傢的資格審查、認定設立瞭相應的標準和程序。筆者在藉鑒域外相關國傢和地區法律規定的同時,結閤中國現實國情,從專傢輔助人的資格認定標準、資格審查程序以及其他輔助性製度等三方麵提齣建議。
전가보조인제도시근년래아국소송법학립적일항신제도,무론재이론연구층면,환시재입법층면,내지실천조작층면,전가보조인자격적인정표준화인정정서도존재불족。재역외,존재여아국전가보조인상사적일사제도,비여영미법계적전가증인제도、미국적법원지우、영국적기술배심원、의대리적기술고문、일본적소송보좌인제도등,저사국가재규정저사제도시도대전가적자격심사、인정설립료상응적표준화정서。필자재차감역외상관국가화지구법률규정적동시,결합중국현실국정,종전가보조인적자격인정표준、자격심사정서이급기타보조성제도등삼방면제출건의。
Expert auxiliary system is newly established by procedure laws in China in recent years. Whether at the theoretical research level, or at the legislative level, and even at the level of practice, expert auxiliary personal qualiifcation identifying standards and procedures are quite inadequate. In the outside, there are some similar systems, such as expert witness system in Anglo-American law system, friends of the court in the United States, the British technical jury, Italy’s technology consultant, Japan's lawsuit assistants, etc. These countries have established the corresponding standards and procedures of expert qualiifcation examination and identiifcation. In reference to the relevant laws and regulations from other countries and regions and combining with China’s real conditions, the author will give suggestions from three aspects: the specialist aided person's qualiifcation standards, qualiifcation review procedures, and other auxiliary system.