福建江夏学院学报
福建江夏學院學報
복건강하학원학보
FUJIAN JIANGXIA XUEYUAN XUEBAO
2014年
6期
50-59
,共10页
民间环保组织%诉讼资格%诉讼地位
民間環保組織%訴訟資格%訴訟地位
민간배보조직%소송자격%소송지위
Grassroots ENGOs%Lawsuit Qualification%Lawsuit Status
工业文明带来了经济的繁荣,也引发了日益严重的生态环境问题。民间环保组织雨后春笋般地出现,是应对生态环境问题的现实需要,也是社会治理的基本表现,还是政府环境监管的有益补充。国内外立法上对民间环保组织的诉讼资格及其与环保行政机关关系的态度宽严不一,这与各国法律文化传统及环保政策导向有关。我国新近出台的《环境保护法》第58条对民间环保组织的诉讼资格的规定过于苛刻,对如何理顺与环境行政机关的关系付诸阙如,这对环境公益诉讼的开展极为不利,有必要对该条进行深刻探讨,并做出详细解释。
工業文明帶來瞭經濟的繁榮,也引髮瞭日益嚴重的生態環境問題。民間環保組織雨後春筍般地齣現,是應對生態環境問題的現實需要,也是社會治理的基本錶現,還是政府環境鑑管的有益補充。國內外立法上對民間環保組織的訴訟資格及其與環保行政機關關繫的態度寬嚴不一,這與各國法律文化傳統及環保政策導嚮有關。我國新近齣檯的《環境保護法》第58條對民間環保組織的訴訟資格的規定過于苛刻,對如何理順與環境行政機關的關繫付諸闕如,這對環境公益訴訟的開展極為不利,有必要對該條進行深刻探討,併做齣詳細解釋。
공업문명대래료경제적번영,야인발료일익엄중적생태배경문제。민간배보조직우후춘순반지출현,시응대생태배경문제적현실수요,야시사회치리적기본표현,환시정부배경감관적유익보충。국내외입법상대민간배보조직적소송자격급기여배보행정궤관관계적태도관엄불일,저여각국법률문화전통급배보정책도향유관。아국신근출태적《배경보호법》제58조대민간배보조직적소송자격적규정과우가각,대여하리순여배경행정궤관적관계부제궐여,저대배경공익소송적개전겁위불리,유필요대해조진행심각탐토,병주출상세해석。
Industrial civilization brings about not only economic prosperity,but also more and more serious ecological environment problems.The springing up of grassroots ENGOs is a practical demand to deal with those problems,a basic performance of social management and a necessary supplement of government environmental regulation.Domestic and abroad legislative attitudes to the lawsuit qualification of the grassroots ENGOs and the relationship between grassroots ENGOs and environmental authorities differ:some are strict,some are loose,those different attitudes have to do with legal tradition and orientation of environmental policy.The regulation on lawsuit qualification of grassroots ENGOs in new environmental protection law article 58 is overstrict and barely touches straightening out relationships between grassroots ENGOs and environmental authorities,which is harmful to expansion of environmental public interest litigation.Therefore,it is necessary to give a profound discussion about Article 58 and promulgate detailed judicial interpretations.