中华内分泌外科杂志
中華內分泌外科雜誌
중화내분비외과잡지
CHINESE JOURNAL OF ENDOCRINE SURGERY
2015年
2期
140-143,151
,共5页
孙海清%曾庆东%吕斌%陈波%李宝元%姜立新%郑海涛
孫海清%曾慶東%呂斌%陳波%李寶元%薑立新%鄭海濤
손해청%증경동%려빈%진파%리보원%강립신%정해도
腔镜辅助甲状腺切除术%完全腔镜甲状腺切除术%安全性%创伤性%美容性
腔鏡輔助甲狀腺切除術%完全腔鏡甲狀腺切除術%安全性%創傷性%美容性
강경보조갑상선절제술%완전강경갑상선절제술%안전성%창상성%미용성
Minimally invasive video-assisted thyroidectomy%Totally endoscopic thyroidectomy%Safety%Trauma%Cosmetic
目的:对比分析腔镜辅助的小切口甲状腺切除术( Miccoli )和完全腔镜的甲状腺切除术(total endoscopic thyroidectomy ,TET)2种手术方式。方法统计分析了山东大学齐鲁医院和烟台毓璜顶医院自2012年1月至12月收治并选择行内镜甲状腺手术的患者共70例,其中行Miccoli术式46例,选择TET 24例(以下称为腔镜组),统计患者的性别、年龄、手术有关数据、术中及术后并发症、住院时间、患者主观感受、美容效果满意度等方面情况并做出分析,以对比2种手术方式在安全性、创伤性和美容效果上的差异。结果①安全性:2组均无永久性喉返神经和甲状旁腺损伤出现,小切口组1例中转开放而腔镜组手术无一中转(2.2%vs 0%,P>0.05)。②创伤性:小切口组术中出血及术后引流量均明显少于腔镜组,P<0.05;术后疼痛评分6 h时2组差异无统计学意义,而12和24 h小切口组疼痛评分要低于腔镜组, P<0.05。术前1 d、术后1 d和术后3 d CRP水平2组间差异无统计学意义,P>0.05。③美容满意度及其他:术后美容效果满意度评分2组差异无统计学意义。结论2种术式安全性类似,都有较好的临床效果;2种术式创伤性类似,均在可接受的范围内;2者美容效果患者满意度类似。
目的:對比分析腔鏡輔助的小切口甲狀腺切除術( Miccoli )和完全腔鏡的甲狀腺切除術(total endoscopic thyroidectomy ,TET)2種手術方式。方法統計分析瞭山東大學齊魯醫院和煙檯毓璜頂醫院自2012年1月至12月收治併選擇行內鏡甲狀腺手術的患者共70例,其中行Miccoli術式46例,選擇TET 24例(以下稱為腔鏡組),統計患者的性彆、年齡、手術有關數據、術中及術後併髮癥、住院時間、患者主觀感受、美容效果滿意度等方麵情況併做齣分析,以對比2種手術方式在安全性、創傷性和美容效果上的差異。結果①安全性:2組均無永久性喉返神經和甲狀徬腺損傷齣現,小切口組1例中轉開放而腔鏡組手術無一中轉(2.2%vs 0%,P>0.05)。②創傷性:小切口組術中齣血及術後引流量均明顯少于腔鏡組,P<0.05;術後疼痛評分6 h時2組差異無統計學意義,而12和24 h小切口組疼痛評分要低于腔鏡組, P<0.05。術前1 d、術後1 d和術後3 d CRP水平2組間差異無統計學意義,P>0.05。③美容滿意度及其他:術後美容效果滿意度評分2組差異無統計學意義。結論2種術式安全性類似,都有較好的臨床效果;2種術式創傷性類似,均在可接受的範圍內;2者美容效果患者滿意度類似。
목적:대비분석강경보조적소절구갑상선절제술( Miccoli )화완전강경적갑상선절제술(total endoscopic thyroidectomy ,TET)2충수술방식。방법통계분석료산동대학제로의원화연태육황정의원자2012년1월지12월수치병선택행내경갑상선수술적환자공70례,기중행Miccoli술식46례,선택TET 24례(이하칭위강경조),통계환자적성별、년령、수술유관수거、술중급술후병발증、주원시간、환자주관감수、미용효과만의도등방면정황병주출분석,이대비2충수술방식재안전성、창상성화미용효과상적차이。결과①안전성:2조균무영구성후반신경화갑상방선손상출현,소절구조1례중전개방이강경조수술무일중전(2.2%vs 0%,P>0.05)。②창상성:소절구조술중출혈급술후인류량균명현소우강경조,P<0.05;술후동통평분6 h시2조차이무통계학의의,이12화24 h소절구조동통평분요저우강경조, P<0.05。술전1 d、술후1 d화술후3 d CRP수평2조간차이무통계학의의,P>0.05。③미용만의도급기타:술후미용효과만의도평분2조차이무통계학의의。결론2충술식안전성유사,도유교호적림상효과;2충술식창상성유사,균재가접수적범위내;2자미용효과환자만의도유사。
Objective To analyze the advantages and disadvantages of minimally invasive video -assisted thyroidectomy(MIVAT)and totally endoscopic thyroidectomy (TET).Methods The study included 70 patients undergoing MIVAT and TET at Qilu Hospital of Shandong University and Yantai Yuhuangding Hospital from Jan . 2012 to Dec.2012.46 patients undergoing MIVAT(MIVAT group)and 24 patients undergoing TET(TET group) were analyzed retrospectively .Data of gender,age,operative data,intraoperative and postoperative complications , length of stay , feelings of patients and cosmetic effect were collected and analyzed .MIVAT and TET were com-pared in terms of safety ,trauma and cosmetic effect .Results ①About safety:no permanent recurrent laryngeal nerve(RLN)palsy and parathyroid injury occurred in either group .One case in MIVAT group and no case in TET group was converted to open surgery (2.2%vs 0%,P>0.05) .②About trauma:the intraoperative blood loss and postoperative drainage amount in the MIVAT group were significantly less than those in the TET group ( P <0.05).Postoperative VAS score at 6 hours was similar,but MIVAT group showed lower postoperative VAS score than TET group at 12 hours and 24 hours ( P<0.05 ) .No significant difference was observed between the 2 groups about C reactive protein (CRP)on the 1st day before operation,the 1st and 3rd day after operation(P>0.05).③About cosmetic effect:the 2 groups had similar patient satisfaction index .Conclusions The study shows similar results in safety and trauma .The 2 approaches are both safe and valid .Patients using the two ap-proaches are equally satisfied with the cosmetic effect .