CAJ | 학술논문

“李丽云案”中，因患者代理人对知情同意权的错误使用，导致了悲剧的发生。知情同意权所体现的，是患者的医疗自主权，而特定情况下，医疗自主权又存在一些局限：非自愿的自愿性、绝对的不容否认性以及形式与内容的矛盾性。这些局限性使得医疗自主权有可能被滥用；而造成权利滥用最直接的原因，则是自主权运行中权利与义务存在不对等性，以及公权力对自主权的运行规制不够。
“리려운안”중，인환자대리인대지정동의권적착오사용，도치료비극적발생。지정동의권소체현적，시환자적의료자주권，이특정정황하，의료자주권우존재일사국한：비자원적자원성、절대적불용부인성이급형식여내용적모순성。저사국한성사득의료자주권유가능피람용；이조성권리람용최직접적원인，칙시자주권운행중권리여의무존재불대등성，이급공권력대자주권적운행규제불구。
In "Li Liyun Case", tragedy happened because of the patient's agent abused informed consent right. Informed consent right reflects the patient's medical autonomy right, but in some specific circumstances, there are some limitations to medical autonomy right: unwilling willingness, absolute undeniability, and the contradiction between form and content. These limitations make it possible for medical autonomy right to be abused, and the most direct reasons for the abuses are: the unequivalence of the rights and obligations in the operation of autonomy right, and the insufficient regulation of the public power in the operation of autonomy right.