北京大学学报(医学版)
北京大學學報(醫學版)
북경대학학보(의학판)
JOURNAL OF BEIJING MEDICAL UNIVERSITY(HEALTH SCIENCES)
2015年
2期
226-231
,共6页
朱以明%姜春岩%鲁谊%李奉龙%李旭%李岳
硃以明%薑春巖%魯誼%李奉龍%李旭%李嶽
주이명%강춘암%로의%리봉룡%리욱%리악
肩脱位%外科手术%骨关节炎
肩脫位%外科手術%骨關節炎
견탈위%외과수술%골관절염
Shoulder dislocation%Surgical procedures,operative%Osteoarthritis
目的:通过病例随访研究总结应用切开Latarjet手术治疗复发性肩关节前脱位的临床疗效。方法:随访22例应用切开Latarjet手术治疗的合并明显肩盂前缘骨缺损的复发性肩关节前脱位患者,平均随访时间为66.0个月。在术前拍摄肩关节X线片以及三维CT以评估术前肩关节骨性关节炎及肩盂骨缺损的严重程度。对患者进行体格检查并采用美国肩肘外科协会( American Shoulder&Elbow Surgeons’ score,ASES)、Constant-Murley和Rowe评分评估肩关节功能及稳定性。术后即刻拍摄肩关节三维CT以检查移位喙突骨块所固定位置。最终随访时,再次拍摄肩关节X线片和三维CT以评估肩关节退行性变的严重程度和喙突骨块的愈合情况,对患者进行体格检查并以前述3种评分标准评价肩关节功能及稳定性。结果:术前患肢平均主动前屈上举158.2°±28.7°,体侧外旋55.3°±15.2°,内旋达T10水平(T3~臀部);平均肩关节ASES评分77.6±17.5,Constant-Murley评分88.3±12.5, Rowe评分40.2±12.0。最终随访时,无患者出现肩关节复发脱位,肩关节平均主动前屈上举167.7°±12.7°,体侧外旋54.3°±16.5°,内旋达 T10水平(T3~L3),与术前相比差异均无统计学意义(P =0.138,P =0.765, P=0.439);平均ASES评分93.7±9.1,Constant-Murley评分95.6±5.6,Rowe评分96.4±4.4,均较术前明显改善(P=0.001,P=0.008,P<0.001)。随访过程中3例患者肩关节退行性改变较术前加重,1例移位喙突骨块不愈合。结论:切开Latarjet手术对合并明显肩盂骨缺损的复发性肩关节前脱位患者有效,术后5年随访观察未发现肩关节骨性关节炎显著加重。
目的:通過病例隨訪研究總結應用切開Latarjet手術治療複髮性肩關節前脫位的臨床療效。方法:隨訪22例應用切開Latarjet手術治療的閤併明顯肩盂前緣骨缺損的複髮性肩關節前脫位患者,平均隨訪時間為66.0箇月。在術前拍攝肩關節X線片以及三維CT以評估術前肩關節骨性關節炎及肩盂骨缺損的嚴重程度。對患者進行體格檢查併採用美國肩肘外科協會( American Shoulder&Elbow Surgeons’ score,ASES)、Constant-Murley和Rowe評分評估肩關節功能及穩定性。術後即刻拍攝肩關節三維CT以檢查移位喙突骨塊所固定位置。最終隨訪時,再次拍攝肩關節X線片和三維CT以評估肩關節退行性變的嚴重程度和喙突骨塊的愈閤情況,對患者進行體格檢查併以前述3種評分標準評價肩關節功能及穩定性。結果:術前患肢平均主動前屈上舉158.2°±28.7°,體側外鏇55.3°±15.2°,內鏇達T10水平(T3~臀部);平均肩關節ASES評分77.6±17.5,Constant-Murley評分88.3±12.5, Rowe評分40.2±12.0。最終隨訪時,無患者齣現肩關節複髮脫位,肩關節平均主動前屈上舉167.7°±12.7°,體側外鏇54.3°±16.5°,內鏇達 T10水平(T3~L3),與術前相比差異均無統計學意義(P =0.138,P =0.765, P=0.439);平均ASES評分93.7±9.1,Constant-Murley評分95.6±5.6,Rowe評分96.4±4.4,均較術前明顯改善(P=0.001,P=0.008,P<0.001)。隨訪過程中3例患者肩關節退行性改變較術前加重,1例移位喙突骨塊不愈閤。結論:切開Latarjet手術對閤併明顯肩盂骨缺損的複髮性肩關節前脫位患者有效,術後5年隨訪觀察未髮現肩關節骨性關節炎顯著加重。
목적:통과병례수방연구총결응용절개Latarjet수술치료복발성견관절전탈위적림상료효。방법:수방22례응용절개Latarjet수술치료적합병명현견우전연골결손적복발성견관절전탈위환자,평균수방시간위66.0개월。재술전박섭견관절X선편이급삼유CT이평고술전견관절골성관절염급견우골결손적엄중정도。대환자진행체격검사병채용미국견주외과협회( American Shoulder&Elbow Surgeons’ score,ASES)、Constant-Murley화Rowe평분평고견관절공능급은정성。술후즉각박섭견관절삼유CT이검사이위훼돌골괴소고정위치。최종수방시,재차박섭견관절X선편화삼유CT이평고견관절퇴행성변적엄중정도화훼돌골괴적유합정황,대환자진행체격검사병이전술3충평분표준평개견관절공능급은정성。결과:술전환지평균주동전굴상거158.2°±28.7°,체측외선55.3°±15.2°,내선체T10수평(T3~둔부);평균견관절ASES평분77.6±17.5,Constant-Murley평분88.3±12.5, Rowe평분40.2±12.0。최종수방시,무환자출현견관절복발탈위,견관절평균주동전굴상거167.7°±12.7°,체측외선54.3°±16.5°,내선체 T10수평(T3~L3),여술전상비차이균무통계학의의(P =0.138,P =0.765, P=0.439);평균ASES평분93.7±9.1,Constant-Murley평분95.6±5.6,Rowe평분96.4±4.4,균교술전명현개선(P=0.001,P=0.008,P<0.001)。수방과정중3례환자견관절퇴행성개변교술전가중,1례이위훼돌골괴불유합。결론:절개Latarjet수술대합병명현견우골결손적복발성견관절전탈위환자유효,술후5년수방관찰미발현견관절골성관절염현저가중。
Objective: To investigate the results of treating patients with recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation using open Latarjet technique in a retrospective study, and to discuss the detail of the surgical technique and the results of the procedure.Methods: In the study, 22 patients with recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation treated with open Latarjet technique were followed up.The average duration of the follow-up was 66.0 months.An X-ray film and a CT scan were performed before the surgery to evaluate the degenerative change of the gleno-humeral joint and the bony defect of the glenoid.An X-ray film and a CT scan were repeated at the end of the final follow-up to find out if there was any progression of the de-generative change of the gleno-humeral joint and if the transferred coracoid process united.Physical ex-aminations, American Shoulder & Elbow Surgeons ( ASES ) score, Constant-Murley score and Rowe questionnaire were used to evaluate the patients’ shoulder function before the surgery and at the end of the final follow-up.Results:Before the surgery the average forward elevation, external rotation and inter-nal rotation were 158.2°±28.7°, 55.3°±15.2°and T10 ( T3 -buttock) respectively.The average ASES score, Constant-Murley score and Rowe score were 77.6 ±17.5, 88.3 ±12.5 and 40.2 ±12.0, respectively.At the end of the final follow-up, no redislocation happened.The average forward eleva-tion, external rotation and internal rotation were 167.7°±12.7°, 54.3°±16.5°and T10 (T3-L3), respectively(P=0.138, P=0.765, P=0.439).No sigificant restriction was detected after the surgery regarding forward elevation,external rotation and internal rotation.The mean ASES score, Constant-Mur-ley score, and Rowe score significantly improved to 93.7 ±9.1 (P=0.001), 95.6 ±5.6 (P=0.008) and 96.4 ±4.4 (P<0.001) respectively after the surgery.A progression of the degenerative change of the gleno-humeral joint was detected in 3 patients.A non-union of the transferred coarcoid was detected in 1 patient.Conclusion:Open Latarjet procedure is effective in treating the recurrent anterior shoulder dislocation patient with severe glenoid defect.No significant progression of the degenerative change of the gleno-humeral joint is detected in average 5-year follow-up.