临床和实验医学杂志
臨床和實驗醫學雜誌
림상화실험의학잡지
JOURNAL OF CLINICAL AND EXPERIMENTAL MEDICINE
2015年
9期
764-767
,共4页
孙红%薛会茹%田慧然%刘素芳%赵永琴
孫紅%薛會茹%田慧然%劉素芳%趙永琴
손홍%설회여%전혜연%류소방%조영금
宫颈癌%新辅助化疗%奥沙利铂%顺铂%多西紫杉醇
宮頸癌%新輔助化療%奧沙利鉑%順鉑%多西紫杉醇
궁경암%신보조화료%오사리박%순박%다서자삼순
Cervical cancer%Neoadjuvant chemotherapy%Oxaliplatin%Cisplatin%Docetaxel
目的:观察并对比奥沙利铂(L - OHP)、顺铂(DDP)分别联合多西紫杉醇(DTX)方案用于 Ib -Ⅱa 期宫颈癌患者新辅助化疗的近远期疗效与安全性,优化临床治疗方案。方法将2010~2011年收治的103例择期行根治术的 Ib -Ⅱa 期宫颈癌患者随机分为 A、B 两组,A 组53例患者术前予 DTX 联合 L - OHP 化疗方案,B 组予 DTX 联合 DDP方案,2周为1化疗周期,连续化疗3个周期,化疗结束后2~3周适情行广泛子宫切除术并盆腔淋巴结清扫,对比两组化疗后近期疗效、化疗期间毒性反应并2年复发率。结果新辅助化疗结束后,A 组 KPS 评分(82.6±5.7)明显高于 B组(80.4±5.3)( t =2.025,P =0.046),A 组总有效率(67.9%)和临床获益率(94.3%)均高于 B 组(54.0%、86.0%),差异无统计学意义( P >0.05)。化疗期间,A 组中性粒细胞减少(11.3% vs.28.0%)、血小板减少(5.7% vs.16.0%)、肾功损害(3.8% vs.14.0%)、脱发(32.1% vs.42.0%)等发生率大幅低于 B 组,两组中性粒细胞减少比率差异有统计学意义(χ2=4.574,P =0.032)。术中,A、B 两组宫旁组织及淋巴结癌阳性率(6.0% vs.11.6%)无显著性差异(fisher P=0.464)。术后2年 A、B 两组复发率(2.4% vs.5.3%)无显著差异(fisher P =0.498)。结论 Ib -Ⅱa 期宫颈癌患者术前采用 DTX 联合 L - OHP 化疗方案较 DTX 联合 DDP 方案在近期疗效方面具有比较优势,在降低骨髓抑制等毒性反应方面优势明显。
目的:觀察併對比奧沙利鉑(L - OHP)、順鉑(DDP)分彆聯閤多西紫杉醇(DTX)方案用于 Ib -Ⅱa 期宮頸癌患者新輔助化療的近遠期療效與安全性,優化臨床治療方案。方法將2010~2011年收治的103例擇期行根治術的 Ib -Ⅱa 期宮頸癌患者隨機分為 A、B 兩組,A 組53例患者術前予 DTX 聯閤 L - OHP 化療方案,B 組予 DTX 聯閤 DDP方案,2週為1化療週期,連續化療3箇週期,化療結束後2~3週適情行廣汎子宮切除術併盆腔淋巴結清掃,對比兩組化療後近期療效、化療期間毒性反應併2年複髮率。結果新輔助化療結束後,A 組 KPS 評分(82.6±5.7)明顯高于 B組(80.4±5.3)( t =2.025,P =0.046),A 組總有效率(67.9%)和臨床穫益率(94.3%)均高于 B 組(54.0%、86.0%),差異無統計學意義( P >0.05)。化療期間,A 組中性粒細胞減少(11.3% vs.28.0%)、血小闆減少(5.7% vs.16.0%)、腎功損害(3.8% vs.14.0%)、脫髮(32.1% vs.42.0%)等髮生率大幅低于 B 組,兩組中性粒細胞減少比率差異有統計學意義(χ2=4.574,P =0.032)。術中,A、B 兩組宮徬組織及淋巴結癌暘性率(6.0% vs.11.6%)無顯著性差異(fisher P=0.464)。術後2年 A、B 兩組複髮率(2.4% vs.5.3%)無顯著差異(fisher P =0.498)。結論 Ib -Ⅱa 期宮頸癌患者術前採用 DTX 聯閤 L - OHP 化療方案較 DTX 聯閤 DDP 方案在近期療效方麵具有比較優勢,在降低骨髓抑製等毒性反應方麵優勢明顯。
목적:관찰병대비오사리박(L - OHP)、순박(DDP)분별연합다서자삼순(DTX)방안용우 Ib -Ⅱa 기궁경암환자신보조화료적근원기료효여안전성,우화림상치료방안。방법장2010~2011년수치적103례택기행근치술적 Ib -Ⅱa 기궁경암환자수궤분위 A、B 량조,A 조53례환자술전여 DTX 연합 L - OHP 화료방안,B 조여 DTX 연합 DDP방안,2주위1화료주기,련속화료3개주기,화료결속후2~3주괄정행엄범자궁절제술병분강림파결청소,대비량조화료후근기료효、화료기간독성반응병2년복발솔。결과신보조화료결속후,A 조 KPS 평분(82.6±5.7)명현고우 B조(80.4±5.3)( t =2.025,P =0.046),A 조총유효솔(67.9%)화림상획익솔(94.3%)균고우 B 조(54.0%、86.0%),차이무통계학의의( P >0.05)。화료기간,A 조중성립세포감소(11.3% vs.28.0%)、혈소판감소(5.7% vs.16.0%)、신공손해(3.8% vs.14.0%)、탈발(32.1% vs.42.0%)등발생솔대폭저우 B 조,량조중성립세포감소비솔차이유통계학의의(χ2=4.574,P =0.032)。술중,A、B 량조궁방조직급림파결암양성솔(6.0% vs.11.6%)무현저성차이(fisher P=0.464)。술후2년 A、B 량조복발솔(2.4% vs.5.3%)무현저차이(fisher P =0.498)。결론 Ib -Ⅱa 기궁경암환자술전채용 DTX 연합 L - OHP 화료방안교 DTX 연합 DDP 방안재근기료효방면구유비교우세,재강저골수억제등독성반응방면우세명현。
Objective To observe and compare short and long term efficacy and safety between oxaliplatin(L - OHP)/ docetaxel(DTX) regimen and cis - platin(DDP)/ DTX regimen for neoadjuvant chemotherapy of Ib - Ⅱa cervical carcinoma,and to optimize treatment plan. Methods One hundred and three Ib - Ⅱa cervical carcinoma patients who underwent radical resection during 2010 ~ 2011 were randomly divided into group A(n = 53)and group B(n = 50). Patients in both received neoadjuvant chemotherapy,group A was treated with L - OHP/ DTX, group B was treated with DDP/ DTX regimen,2 weeks for 1 treatment cycle,and continuously for 3 cycles. 2 - 3 weeks after neoadjuvant chemo-therapy,extensive hysterectomy and pelvic lymph node dissection were implemented,and short term efficacy,toxicity reactions and 2 years recur-rence rate of 2 groups were compared. Results After neoadjuvant chemotherapy,KPS score in group A(82. 6 + 5. 7)was higher than group B (80. 4 + 5. 3)( t = 2. 025,P = 0. 046). The total effective rate of group A(67. 9% )and clinical benefit rate(94. 3% )in group A were higher than group B(54. 0% and 86. 0% ,respectively),but no significant differences( P > 0. 05). During chemotherapy,incidence of neutropenia, thrombocytopenia,renal damage,and hair loss in group A and group B were11. 3% vs. 28. 0% ,5. 7% vs. 16. 0% ,3. 8% vs. 14. 0% ,and 32. 1% vs. 42. 0% ,respectively. There was statistically significant difference in neutropenia ratio(χ2 = 4. 574,P = 0. 032). During operation,no significant difference in parametrial tissue and lymph node cancer positive rate was found between group A and group B(6% vs. 11. 6% )(fisher P = 0. 464). Two years after surgery,the recurrence rate in group A and group B(2. 4% vs. 5. 3% )had no significant difference(Fisher P =0. 498). Conclusion Compared with DDP/ DTX regimen,L - OHP/ DTX neoadjuvant chemotherapy has comparative advantages in short term ef-ficacy for Ib - Ⅱa cervical carcinoma,and has obvious advantages in reduction of bone marrow inhibition.