中医临床研究
中醫臨床研究
중의림상연구
CLINICAL JOURNAL OF CHINESE MEDICINE
2015年
11期
146-148
,共3页
胡晓英%周国平%张昕%龚后武
鬍曉英%週國平%張昕%龔後武
호효영%주국평%장흔%공후무
针刺结合康复训练%中风后足内翻%Meta分析
針刺結閤康複訓練%中風後足內翻%Meta分析
침자결합강복훈련%중풍후족내번%Meta분석
Acupuncture combined with rehabilitation therapy%Strephenopodia after stroke%Meta-Analysis
目的:分析针刺结合康复训练治疗中风后足内翻的疗效。方法:通过电子检索,并且结合专业资料以及网络上的信息,采用RevMan5软件(由Cochrane协作网提供)实行Meta分析。结果:共查及了115篇文献,只有5篇文献符合纳入标准。采用Jadad评分标准对纳入文章的方法和结果进行评价,5篇均属低质量文献,共收入病人324人,Mate分析显示,针刺结合康复训练治疗中风后足内翻总有效率优于对照组,其汇总OR=3.15,95% CI(1.74,5.71),其差异有统计学意义(Z=3.79,P=0.0001)。结论:现有的临床研究证据显示,针刺结合康复训练治疗中风后足内翻在总有效率方面优于单纯康复训练,纳入文献均属RCT但治疗较低,需要大规模的高质量临床试验研究以期得到强度更高的证据。
目的:分析針刺結閤康複訓練治療中風後足內翻的療效。方法:通過電子檢索,併且結閤專業資料以及網絡上的信息,採用RevMan5軟件(由Cochrane協作網提供)實行Meta分析。結果:共查及瞭115篇文獻,隻有5篇文獻符閤納入標準。採用Jadad評分標準對納入文章的方法和結果進行評價,5篇均屬低質量文獻,共收入病人324人,Mate分析顯示,針刺結閤康複訓練治療中風後足內翻總有效率優于對照組,其彙總OR=3.15,95% CI(1.74,5.71),其差異有統計學意義(Z=3.79,P=0.0001)。結論:現有的臨床研究證據顯示,針刺結閤康複訓練治療中風後足內翻在總有效率方麵優于單純康複訓練,納入文獻均屬RCT但治療較低,需要大規模的高質量臨床試驗研究以期得到彊度更高的證據。
목적:분석침자결합강복훈련치료중풍후족내번적료효。방법:통과전자검색,병차결합전업자료이급망락상적신식,채용RevMan5연건(유Cochrane협작망제공)실행Meta분석。결과:공사급료115편문헌,지유5편문헌부합납입표준。채용Jadad평분표준대납입문장적방법화결과진행평개,5편균속저질량문헌,공수입병인324인,Mate분석현시,침자결합강복훈련치료중풍후족내번총유효솔우우대조조,기회총OR=3.15,95% CI(1.74,5.71),기차이유통계학의의(Z=3.79,P=0.0001)。결론:현유적림상연구증거현시,침자결합강복훈련치료중풍후족내번재총유효솔방면우우단순강복훈련,납입문헌균속RCT단치료교저,수요대규모적고질량림상시험연구이기득도강도경고적증거。
Objective: To analyze the efficacy of acupuncture by rehabilitation training on strephenopodia following apoplexia. Methods: Via electronic retrieval, and combine the information on the professional data and networking. By using RevMan5 software (provided by the Cochrane Collaboration) Meta-analysis of the implementation. Results: A total of 115 investigations and literature, only five met the inclusion criteria. Using Jadad scoring criteria included articles on the methods and results were evaluated, five are low-quality literature, a total income of 324 patients, Mate analysis showed that acupuncture combined with rehabilitation after stroke total strephenopodia efficient than the control group its summary OR=3.15,95% CI (1.74,5.71) and the difference was statistically significant (Z = 3.79,P= 0.0001). Conclusion: Existing clinical research evidence shows that acupuncture combined with rehabilitation Strephenopodia after stroke in terms of total efficiency due to simple rehabilitation training, included literature are RCT but lower treatment, high-quality clinical trials research needs to scale evidence obtain higher strength.