福建警察学院学报
福建警察學院學報
복건경찰학원학보
JOURNAL OF FUJIAN POLICE ACADEMY
2015年
3期
73-78,84
,共7页
“廉政账户”%理论困境%制度废除%刑法学
“廉政賬戶”%理論睏境%製度廢除%刑法學
“렴정장호”%이론곤경%제도폐제%형법학
"Honesty Account"%dilemma%abolition%criminal law
“廉政账户”制度作为一项反腐机制,其本身的构造比较混乱。从刑法学的角度来看:“廉政账户”制度在理论上存在着与刑法基本原则和刑法基本理论相冲突等困境,在实践中存在着缺乏法律依据、助长贿赂犯罪蔓延等困境;同时,“廉政账户”制度所解决的问题完全可以通过现行法律和规范予以解决。因此,“廉政账户”制度应当予以废除。
“廉政賬戶”製度作為一項反腐機製,其本身的構造比較混亂。從刑法學的角度來看:“廉政賬戶”製度在理論上存在著與刑法基本原則和刑法基本理論相遲突等睏境,在實踐中存在著缺乏法律依據、助長賄賂犯罪蔓延等睏境;同時,“廉政賬戶”製度所解決的問題完全可以通過現行法律和規範予以解決。因此,“廉政賬戶”製度應噹予以廢除。
“렴정장호”제도작위일항반부궤제,기본신적구조비교혼란。종형법학적각도래간:“렴정장호”제도재이론상존재착여형법기본원칙화형법기본이론상충돌등곤경,재실천중존재착결핍법률의거、조장회뢰범죄만연등곤경;동시,“렴정장호”제도소해결적문제완전가이통과현행법률화규범여이해결。인차,“렴정장호”제도응당여이폐제。
As a system of anti -corruption, the structure of "Honesty Account" system is very confusing. From the view of criminal law,"Honesty Account" system has, in theory, fallen in conflict with the basic principle and theory of criminal law , and in practice, faced with the lack of legal basis and stimulation for the spread of bribery crime. Meanwhile, what"Honesty Account" system is dealing with could be solved totally by the laws and regulations that are available nowadays. As a result,"Honesty Account" system should be abolished.