CAJ | 학술논문

针对目前跨学科研究越来越多，传统期刊评价指标不适合跨学科期刊评价这一问题，介绍由Vinkler提出的一种评价期刊影响力的PRP指标，该指标通过挖掘期刊中高影响力论文的引文信息来评价期刊质量，同时以每一篇精英论文在本领域的被引量排名为依据进行学科领域特征的控制，从而可实现跨学科领域的期刊评价。但由于Vinkler使用的精英论文集界定方法对期刊发文量大小过于依赖，使得评价结果过于偏好发文量大的期刊，为解决这一问题，对精英论文集的界定方法加以改进。通过对6个学科领域、111种核心期刊的实证分析，进一步阐明其计算步骤和效果，并分析其与期刊H指数的异同。实证分析结果表明，改进后的PRP指标基本能够实现跨学科期刊评价，与H指数相比，由于使用PRP指标对样本期刊进行评价，得到的分数值更加离散，从而具有更好的区分度；由于精英论文的被引量都会对结果产生影响，从而在一定程度上克服了H指数较容易受人为控制这一缺陷。
침대목전과학과연구월래월다，전통기간평개지표불괄합과학과기간평개저일문제，개소유Vinkler제출적일충평개기간영향력적PRP지표，해지표통과알굴기간중고영향력논문적인문신식래평개기간질량，동시이매일편정영논문재본영역적피인량배명위의거진행학과영역특정적공제，종이가실현과학과영역적기간평개。단유우Vinkler사용적정영논문집계정방법대기간발문량대소과우의뢰，사득평개결과과우편호발문량대적기간，위해결저일문제，대정영논문집적계정방법가이개진。통과대6개학과영역、111충핵심기간적실증분석，진일보천명기계산보취화효과，병분석기여기간H지수적이동。실증분석결과표명，개진후적PRP지표기본능구실현과학과기간평개，여H지수상비，유우사용PRP지표대양본기간진행평개，득도적분수치경가리산，종이구유경호적구분도；유우정영논문적피인량도회대결과산생영향，종이재일정정도상극복료H지수교용역수인위공제저일결함。
Interdisciplinary scientific research is getting more and more attention, and it is impossible to use traditional evaluation methods to evaluate this type of research. Aimed to solve this problem, the paper introduces a new method, PRP-index, for evaluating the journals of different research fields proposed by Vinkler, the method is based on the information included in the papers with high citations. In view of the fact that the production has too great an impact on the evaluations, this study makes some modifications on it. The calculation process is analyzed. The similarities and differences compared with H index are summarized. As an example, the PRP-index and H index of 111 core journals in 6 different research fields are calculated, the result and reasons are analyzed. The empirical research shows the effect of the PRP-index in evaluating the scientific journals of different research fields.