东方论坛
東方論罈
동방론단
ORIENTAL FORUM
2015年
4期
84-90
,共7页
“新史学”%唯物史观%综合史观%历史编纂
“新史學”%唯物史觀%綜閤史觀%歷史編纂
“신사학”%유물사관%종합사관%역사편찬
new historiography%historical materialism%comprehensive historical view%historical compilation
以往将“新史学”限定于20世纪初至“五四”前后的做法并不准确,实则,其与新历史考证学、马克思主义史学一齐构成民国时期中国史学的基本格局。新史学学者对唯物史观采取既接受又批评的态度,常以“经济史观”对其理论内核加以定位,并试图建构“综合史观”与之抗衡,从而实现理论体系的更新。此外,他们还依照各自的理解将唯物史观熔铸于史书编纂及对历史现象、历史事件、历史人物的分析和评价中。唯物史观对新史学的广泛影响说明,马克思主义史学的发展、壮大乃是源自理论体系的先进以及研究成绩的突出,是学术发展的逻辑结果,而非政治的产物。
以往將“新史學”限定于20世紀初至“五四”前後的做法併不準確,實則,其與新歷史攷證學、馬剋思主義史學一齊構成民國時期中國史學的基本格跼。新史學學者對唯物史觀採取既接受又批評的態度,常以“經濟史觀”對其理論內覈加以定位,併試圖建構“綜閤史觀”與之抗衡,從而實現理論體繫的更新。此外,他們還依照各自的理解將唯物史觀鎔鑄于史書編纂及對歷史現象、歷史事件、歷史人物的分析和評價中。唯物史觀對新史學的廣汎影響說明,馬剋思主義史學的髮展、壯大迺是源自理論體繫的先進以及研究成績的突齣,是學術髮展的邏輯結果,而非政治的產物。
이왕장“신사학”한정우20세기초지“오사”전후적주법병불준학,실칙,기여신역사고증학、마극사주의사학일제구성민국시기중국사학적기본격국。신사학학자대유물사관채취기접수우비평적태도,상이“경제사관”대기이론내핵가이정위,병시도건구“종합사관”여지항형,종이실현이론체계적경신。차외,타문환의조각자적리해장유물사관용주우사서편찬급대역사현상、역사사건、역사인물적분석화평개중。유물사관대신사학적엄범영향설명,마극사주의사학적발전、장대내시원자이론체계적선진이급연구성적적돌출,시학술발전적라집결과,이비정치적산물。
New historiography, which is improperly restricted to the beginning of the 20th century and the May 4th Movement period, gradually developed into a great school which evolved hand in hand with the new historical textual research school and the Marxist school of historiography. The new historiography school adopted an eclectic attitude towards historical materialism and tried to establish a comprehensive historical view to update the theoretical system and contend with it. Historical materialism was also applied to historical research in accordance with respective understandings. The development of the Marxist historiography is propelled by its advanced theoretical system. It was the logical result of academic rather than political development.