外交评论:外交学院学报
外交評論:外交學院學報
외교평론:외교학원학보
Foreign Affairs Review
2005年
4期
101~104
,共null页
坚持反对者学说 适用规则 效力依据
堅持反對者學說 適用規則 效力依據
견지반대자학설 괄용규칙 효력의거
Doctrine of Persistent Objector; Applicable Rules; Legal Basis
国际习惯的普遍的拘束力并非绝对的,在实践中,国家可以适用"坚持反对者学说",通过持续反对来排除某个正在形成的国家习惯的适用.适用该学说必须满足一些规则,例如反对必须在合理的时间内提出等等.该学说以"默示同意说"为理论基础,本文认为从该理论基础出发,该学说在一定程度上对各国维护本国主权和国家利益是有积极作用的.
國際習慣的普遍的拘束力併非絕對的,在實踐中,國傢可以適用"堅持反對者學說",通過持續反對來排除某箇正在形成的國傢習慣的適用.適用該學說必鬚滿足一些規則,例如反對必鬚在閤理的時間內提齣等等.該學說以"默示同意說"為理論基礎,本文認為從該理論基礎齣髮,該學說在一定程度上對各國維護本國主權和國傢利益是有積極作用的.
국제습관적보편적구속력병비절대적,재실천중,국가가이괄용"견지반대자학설",통과지속반대래배제모개정재형성적국가습관적괄용.괄용해학설필수만족일사규칙,례여반대필수재합리적시간내제출등등.해학설이"묵시동의설"위이론기출,본문인위종해이론기출출발,해학설재일정정도상대각국유호본국주권화국가이익시유적겁작용적.
It is well-known that international customary law is capable of creating universally binding rules. The rules that govern its formation allow states to gain an exemption from emerging norms of customary law, that is, Doctrine of Persistent Objector. The doctrine gives states an opportunity to avoid binding force of customary law by objecting to it. To invoke the doctrine some elements must be met. For example, the objection should be raised within a reasonable period. The force of the doctrine rests on the implied consent of states. Then it is good to states to protect their interest.