周口师范学院学报
週口師範學院學報
주구사범학원학보
Journal of Zhoukou Normal University
2006年
1期
97~99
,共null页
逻辑 形而上学 判断标准
邏輯 形而上學 判斷標準
라집 형이상학 판단표준
logic; metaphysics; criterion
卡尔纳普在《通过语言的逻辑分析清除形而上学》一文中宣称可以用逻辑的方法终结形而上学。然而其论述并非无懈可击,并不能使人信服。文章从其应用逻辑标准自身的合理性,逻辑分析方法与其“科学性”的主张存在自相矛盾的因素,实证逻辑的标准在经验领域内运用等方面,对卡尔纳普的观点提出了质疑。
卡爾納普在《通過語言的邏輯分析清除形而上學》一文中宣稱可以用邏輯的方法終結形而上學。然而其論述併非無懈可擊,併不能使人信服。文章從其應用邏輯標準自身的閤理性,邏輯分析方法與其“科學性”的主張存在自相矛盾的因素,實證邏輯的標準在經驗領域內運用等方麵,對卡爾納普的觀點提齣瞭質疑。
잡이납보재《통과어언적라집분석청제형이상학》일문중선칭가이용라집적방법종결형이상학。연이기논술병비무해가격,병불능사인신복。문장종기응용라집표준자신적합이성,라집분석방법여기“과학성”적주장존재자상모순적인소,실증라집적표준재경험영역내운용등방면,대잡이납보적관점제출료질의。
In his article "To Eliminate Metaphysics Through Logical Analysis of Language", Carnap argues that metaphysics can be eliminated through logical approaches, which is not invulnerable and convincing. From several aspects, the rationahty of his application of logical criterion, there were some self- eontradietory factors between his logical analysis method and his statement "to be scientific", the application of the criterion of logical positivism on empirical field, etc. , this paper raises a query on Carnap's point of view.