韶关学院学报
韶關學院學報
소관학원학보
Journal of Shaoguan University(Social Science Edition)
2006年
7期
31~34
,共null页
暂予监外执行 立法缺陷 检察监督
暫予鑑外執行 立法缺陷 檢察鑑督
잠여감외집행 입법결함 검찰감독
temporary execution outside prison; defects of legislation; the supervise of procurator
有关暂予监外执行的现行立法存在以下缺陷：由于法律规定的原因，造成对监外执行罪犯监管不力；延长保外就医时对罪犯的考察方式具有任意性，延长期限的条件不够严格，导致保外就医期限恣意延长；收监条件粗疏，收监情形有疏漏；检察监督范围不够全面，缺少有力的监督措施以及监督缺乏权威性。
有關暫予鑑外執行的現行立法存在以下缺陷：由于法律規定的原因，造成對鑑外執行罪犯鑑管不力；延長保外就醫時對罪犯的攷察方式具有任意性，延長期限的條件不夠嚴格，導緻保外就醫期限恣意延長；收鑑條件粗疏，收鑑情形有疏漏；檢察鑑督範圍不夠全麵，缺少有力的鑑督措施以及鑑督缺乏權威性。
유관잠여감외집행적현행입법존재이하결함：유우법률규정적원인，조성대감외집행죄범감관불력；연장보외취의시대죄범적고찰방식구유임의성，연장기한적조건불구엄격，도치보외취의기한자의연장；수감조건조소，수감정형유소루；검찰감독범위불구전면，결소유력적감독조시이급감독결핍권위성。
The concerning current lawmaking of temporary execution outside prison exists the following blemish： because of the reason of the law provision, giving rise to that the criminal being executed outside prision can not be well supervised; the manner of review to prolong the period is very random, the term of prolong period is not strict enough which produce arbitrariness when prolong the period of execution outside prison; the condition to throw into prison is inattentive and the situations of throwing criminal into prison contain careless omission; the scope of the supervise of procurator is not completely; be short of effective measures, the supervise of procurator has no authority.
