西安财经学院学报
西安財經學院學報
서안재경학원학보
Journal of Xi‘an Institute of Finance & Economics
2008年
6期
120~124
,共null页
行政犯罪 严格责任 可行性 合理架构
行政犯罪 嚴格責任 可行性 閤理架構
행정범죄 엄격책임 가행성 합리가구
administrative offense; strict liability; feasibility; reasonable framework
英美刑法中的严格责任主要体现在“公共福利犯罪”和“道德犯罪”等方面,因而严格责任在行政犯罪中有较多适用。在我国,行政犯罪的外延范围与英美刑法严格责任的适用范围存在着一种交叉重叠关系。因此,在我国行政犯罪中,特别是交叉重叠部分引入严格责任是可行且有益的。在行政犯罪中架构严格责任理论,宜对其主观罪过表述模糊化;在法定刑上,适用严格责任的行政犯罪的处罚,应较适用非严格责任的犯罪处罚为轻;同时,应完善举证责任分配制度,建立证据救济制度。
英美刑法中的嚴格責任主要體現在“公共福利犯罪”和“道德犯罪”等方麵,因而嚴格責任在行政犯罪中有較多適用。在我國,行政犯罪的外延範圍與英美刑法嚴格責任的適用範圍存在著一種交扠重疊關繫。因此,在我國行政犯罪中,特彆是交扠重疊部分引入嚴格責任是可行且有益的。在行政犯罪中架構嚴格責任理論,宜對其主觀罪過錶述模糊化;在法定刑上,適用嚴格責任的行政犯罪的處罰,應較適用非嚴格責任的犯罪處罰為輕;同時,應完善舉證責任分配製度,建立證據救濟製度。
영미형법중적엄격책임주요체현재“공공복리범죄”화“도덕범죄”등방면,인이엄격책임재행정범죄중유교다괄용。재아국,행정범죄적외연범위여영미형법엄격책임적괄용범위존재착일충교차중첩관계。인차,재아국행정범죄중,특별시교차중첩부분인입엄격책임시가행차유익적。재행정범죄중가구엄격책임이론,의대기주관죄과표술모호화;재법정형상,괄용엄격책임적행정범죄적처벌,응교괄용비엄격책임적범죄처벌위경;동시,응완선거증책임분배제도,건립증거구제제도。
The strict liability is mainly reflected in such as the public welfare crime and moral crime in the Britain and the United States criminal law. Thus strict liability is used very often in the administrative offense. There is a cross and overlap relationship between the extension of the scope of administrative offense in our country and the scope of strict liability's application in the Britain and the United States criminal law. Therefore, the intro- duction of strict liability is feasible and useful in our administrative offense, especially in the above - mentioned overlaping part(mainly related to public health, social welfare, environmental protection and other aspects of the crime). The strict liability theory' s framework in the administrative offense should be: let the Statements about administrative offense's subjective sin be vague; punish about the administrative offense that apply strict liability should be less strict than the offense which not apply such theory; at the same time, the burden of evidence's distribution system should be improved, evidence relief system also should be established.