华中农业大学学报:社会科学版
華中農業大學學報:社會科學版
화중농업대학학보:사회과학판
Journal of Huazhong Agricultural University(Social Sciences Edition)
2009年
3期
118~123
,共null页
公平原则 发展 适用 东海大陆架划界
公平原則 髮展 適用 東海大陸架劃界
공평원칙 발전 괄용 동해대륙가화계
Equitable Principle; development; application; delimitation of East China Sea Continental Shelf
衡平原则是大陆架划界中已经确立的习惯法规则,它的基本理念可以追溯到1909年常设仲裁法院的瑞典和挪威格里期巴丹那岛案。在该案中,常设仲裁法院首次“衡平考虑”了现实情况。在随后的国际实践中,各国都将衡平原则作为大陆架划界的前提和基础,经过国际法院和国际司法实践的推动,衡平原则逐步成为大陆架划界中受到普遍承认的习惯法规则。文章从衡平原则的发展过程人手,分析了衡平原则的法律地位和发展趋势,认为在中日东海大陆架划界中,衡平原则应当是首先适用的国际法规则。
衡平原則是大陸架劃界中已經確立的習慣法規則,它的基本理唸可以追溯到1909年常設仲裁法院的瑞典和挪威格裏期巴丹那島案。在該案中,常設仲裁法院首次“衡平攷慮”瞭現實情況。在隨後的國際實踐中,各國都將衡平原則作為大陸架劃界的前提和基礎,經過國際法院和國際司法實踐的推動,衡平原則逐步成為大陸架劃界中受到普遍承認的習慣法規則。文章從衡平原則的髮展過程人手,分析瞭衡平原則的法律地位和髮展趨勢,認為在中日東海大陸架劃界中,衡平原則應噹是首先適用的國際法規則。
형평원칙시대륙가화계중이경학립적습관법규칙,타적기본이념가이추소도1909년상설중재법원적서전화나위격리기파단나도안。재해안중,상설중재법원수차“형평고필”료현실정황。재수후적국제실천중,각국도장형평원칙작위대륙가화계적전제화기출,경과국제법원화국제사법실천적추동,형평원칙축보성위대륙가화계중수도보편승인적습관법규칙。문장종형평원칙적발전과정인수,분석료형평원칙적법률지위화발전추세,인위재중일동해대륙가화계중,형평원칙응당시수선괄용적국제법규칙。
The Equitable Principle is the customary international law progressively developed in the practice of continental shelf delimitation, which could date back to the Grisbadarna Case between Sweden and Norway (the Permanent Court of Arbitration) in 1909. In that case, the PCA (Permanent Court of Arbitration) considered the relevant circumstances related to "equitability" for the first time. In the following international practice, the ICJ and other international institutions applied and developed the Equitable Principle when they made judgment on the delimitation of continental shelf. As a result, the Equitable Principle has become the customary international law in the delimitation of continental shelf. Based on the development of equitable principle,this paper analyzes the legal status and the developing trends of the Equitable Principle, and concludes that the Equitable Principle should be first applied in the SinoJapan Continental Shelf Delimitation.