北方法学
北方法學
북방법학
NORTHERN LEGAL SCIENCE
2009年
5期
115~123
,共null页
证据审查 证据筛选 证据评价 分离模式 融合模式
證據審查 證據篩選 證據評價 分離模式 融閤模式
증거심사 증거사선 증거평개 분리모식 융합모식
evidence examination ; evidence screening ; evidence evaluating; separation mode ; integral mode
近年来学界对于证据规则的研究已经相当深入，对于证据审查的相关机制却疏于关注。证据审查包括证据筛选和证据评价两个相对独立的环节。英美法系国家证据审查的“分离模式”与大陆法系国家证据审查的“融合模式”各有优劣。我国证据审查模式选择的基本思路是将证据筛选和证据评价适度分离、对证据筛选活动进行诉讼化改造以及完善证据评价机制。
近年來學界對于證據規則的研究已經相噹深入，對于證據審查的相關機製卻疏于關註。證據審查包括證據篩選和證據評價兩箇相對獨立的環節。英美法繫國傢證據審查的“分離模式”與大陸法繫國傢證據審查的“融閤模式”各有優劣。我國證據審查模式選擇的基本思路是將證據篩選和證據評價適度分離、對證據篩選活動進行訴訟化改造以及完善證據評價機製。
근년래학계대우증거규칙적연구이경상당심입，대우증거심사적상관궤제각소우관주。증거심사포괄증거사선화증거평개량개상대독립적배절。영미법계국가증거심사적“분리모식”여대륙법계국가증거심사적“융합모식”각유우렬。아국증거심사모식선택적기본사로시장증거사선화증거평개괄도분리、대증거사선활동진행소송화개조이급완선증거평개궤제。
Compared with the study on evidence rules, the mechanism of evidence examination arouses less concern by scholars. Evidence examination can be divided into two stages of evidence screening and evidence evaluating. As for the mechanism of evidence examination, both the separation mode in the Common Law System and the integral mode in the Civil Law System have their own merits and defects. The ideal choice for our country is to adopt moderate separation mode of evidence screening and evidence evaluating, to introduce litigation mechanism for evidence screening and to perfect the mechanism of evidence evaluating.
