河南省政法管理干部学院学报
河南省政法管理榦部學院學報
하남성정법관리간부학원학보
Journal of Henan Administrative Institute of Politics and Law
2010年
1期
102~109
,共null页
罗马法 法国民法典 德国民法典 人身权 人格权 我国民商法典
囉馬法 法國民法典 德國民法典 人身權 人格權 我國民商法典
라마법 법국민법전 덕국민법전 인신권 인격권 아국민상법전
Roman law ; The French Civil Code ; The German Civil Code ; right of the person ; personality right; China Civil and Commercial Code
人格与主体资格及主体身份密切相关,人格权乃重要的主体权利。罗马法虽然没有人格权之说,但有人格权之内容,且对后来的民法典产生很大影响,尤其对《法国民法典》影响巨大。《法国民法典》在理性主义和自由主义的影响下采取了整体的人格权观点,法典在立法技术上采取概括的人格权保护方式;随社会的发展,新的人格权能不断被吸纳进去,故未产生一般人格权制度。而《德国民法典》受实证主义和康德伦理人格主义哲学的影响,坚信法定人格权观点,法典采取列举式人格权保护,在后来的发展中显现出明显的不足。其后,在法理学的发展下,借助判例确立了一般人格权制度,且对德国族民法典产生了一定影响。其他一些国家的民法典也对一般人格权制度的形成起了一定作用。人格权立法模式的发展变化将为我国民商立法带来一些启示,不仅可以增强我国确立该制度的主动性,而且从立法技巧上,可以将传统人格权置于人身权之中,在我国《民法通则》规定的人身权制度的基础上建立起具有中国特色的人格权制度。
人格與主體資格及主體身份密切相關,人格權迺重要的主體權利。囉馬法雖然沒有人格權之說,但有人格權之內容,且對後來的民法典產生很大影響,尤其對《法國民法典》影響巨大。《法國民法典》在理性主義和自由主義的影響下採取瞭整體的人格權觀點,法典在立法技術上採取概括的人格權保護方式;隨社會的髮展,新的人格權能不斷被吸納進去,故未產生一般人格權製度。而《德國民法典》受實證主義和康德倫理人格主義哲學的影響,堅信法定人格權觀點,法典採取列舉式人格權保護,在後來的髮展中顯現齣明顯的不足。其後,在法理學的髮展下,藉助判例確立瞭一般人格權製度,且對德國族民法典產生瞭一定影響。其他一些國傢的民法典也對一般人格權製度的形成起瞭一定作用。人格權立法模式的髮展變化將為我國民商立法帶來一些啟示,不僅可以增彊我國確立該製度的主動性,而且從立法技巧上,可以將傳統人格權置于人身權之中,在我國《民法通則》規定的人身權製度的基礎上建立起具有中國特色的人格權製度。
인격여주체자격급주체신빈밀절상관,인격권내중요적주체권리。라마법수연몰유인격권지설,단유인격권지내용,차대후래적민법전산생흔대영향,우기대《법국민법전》영향거대。《법국민법전》재이성주의화자유주의적영향하채취료정체적인격권관점,법전재입법기술상채취개괄적인격권보호방식;수사회적발전,신적인격권능불단피흡납진거,고미산생일반인격권제도。이《덕국민법전》수실증주의화강덕윤리인격주의철학적영향,견신법정인격권관점,법전채취열거식인격권보호,재후래적발전중현현출명현적불족。기후,재법이학적발전하,차조판례학립료일반인격권제도,차대덕국족민법전산생료일정영향。기타일사국가적민법전야대일반인격권제도적형성기료일정작용。인격권입법모식적발전변화장위아국민상입법대래일사계시,불부가이증강아국학립해제도적주동성,이차종입법기교상,가이장전통인격권치우인신권지중,재아국《민법통칙》규정적인신권제도적기출상건립기구유중국특색적인격권제도。
Identity of the principal and the principal qualification is closely related to Personality, and personality rights is an important right. Although there is no general personality of the Roman law, there is the core of general personality,and it have a huge impact on the subsequent Civil Code, In particular, a tremendous impact on the "French Civil Code". under the influence of rationalism and liberalism, The Code take the fight of overall personality, it take protection methods of general personality fight in the Legislative technically, With the development of society ,The new personality right can be absorbed constantly, there is not the necessary and possible of produce of General personality system, and yet"German Civil Code" is effected by positivism and Kant's ethical philosophy of personality, it Convinced that the personality right must be legal,The Code take Listing to protect moral rights,in the subsequent development it demonstrate a clear lack.. As a result, In the under development of jurisprudence It establish a general personality system by Case, And have a greater impact on the family of the Civil Code of the German. others of the Civil Code in the world also play a certain influence on bringforth of general personality system, development and changes of the right of Personality' s legislative models bring some enlightenment to the our National Business Council,it not only can enhance our initiative to establish the system, but also the traditional right of personality can be placed among Personal rights from the legislative technique, On the basis of our "Civil Law" about personal rights system established moral rights system with Chinese characteristics.