西藏大学学报
西藏大學學報
서장대학학보
Journal of Tibet University
2010年
2期
134~138
,共null页
检察委员会 回避制度 整体回避 实体公正 程序公正
檢察委員會 迴避製度 整體迴避 實體公正 程序公正
검찰위원회 회피제도 정체회피 실체공정 정서공정
the Procuratorial Committee; challenge system; whole challenge; substantive justice; procedural fairness
我国检察委会的回避制度存在诸多漏洞和弊端,由于立法上没有明确的规定,导致在司法实务方面缺乏操作的可能性。作为一个保障实体公正的诉讼程序,检察委员会的回避制度能否发挥其应有的功效,不能单单依赖回避制度本身,还需要完善该制度的上游和下游的其他相关联的诉讼制度。文章认为,构建检察委员会的回避制度不仅有利于确保实体公正和程序公正的实现,而且有利于增强司法的权威性,维护社会的和谐稳定。
我國檢察委會的迴避製度存在諸多漏洞和弊耑,由于立法上沒有明確的規定,導緻在司法實務方麵缺乏操作的可能性。作為一箇保障實體公正的訴訟程序,檢察委員會的迴避製度能否髮揮其應有的功效,不能單單依賴迴避製度本身,還需要完善該製度的上遊和下遊的其他相關聯的訴訟製度。文章認為,構建檢察委員會的迴避製度不僅有利于確保實體公正和程序公正的實現,而且有利于增彊司法的權威性,維護社會的和諧穩定。
아국검찰위회적회피제도존재제다루동화폐단,유우입법상몰유명학적규정,도치재사법실무방면결핍조작적가능성。작위일개보장실체공정적소송정서,검찰위원회적회피제도능부발휘기응유적공효,불능단단의뢰회피제도본신,환수요완선해제도적상유화하유적기타상관련적소송제도。문장인위,구건검찰위원회적회피제도불부유리우학보실체공정화정서공정적실현,이차유리우증강사법적권위성,유호사회적화해은정。
The Challenge system of the Procuratorial Committee in China has many loopholes and drawbacks.Because of no explicit legislative provision in legislation,it results in the lack of operational possibility in judicial practice.As a judicial procedure guaranteeing substantive justice,whether the Challenge system of the Procuratorial Committee can fulfill its proper function or not,should not only rely on the Challenge system itself,but also need to consummate other associated litigation system of the upper and lower chains of the Challenge system,such as the inspection open system,the whole challenge system,etc.The paper claims that the Challenge system of the Procuratorial Committee helps not only ensure the implementation of substantive justice and procedural fairness,but also strengthen the judicial authority and maintain social harmony and stability.