青岛科技大学学报:社会科学版
青島科技大學學報:社會科學版
청도과기대학학보:사회과학판
Journal of Qingdao University of Science and Technology
2010年
4期
88~95
,共null页
仲裁员制度 缺陷 运行失范 矫正
仲裁員製度 缺陷 運行失範 矯正
중재원제도 결함 운행실범 교정
arbitrator system; defect; operation without standard; correction
仲裁员队伍是仲裁制度的脊梁,仲裁员则是仲裁的灵魂。自1995年9月1日仲裁法实施以来,我国的仲裁事业在十几年的时间里取得了长足的发展。然而,近年来仲裁员制度的缺陷及制度运行失范亦日渐凸显,其主要表现为:仲裁员法定条件宽松,聘任仲裁员不合条件,名册仲裁员信息量不足,当事人选定仲裁员盲目,选择首席、独任仲裁员权利落空,驻会仲裁员大量存在,仲裁诉讼化倾向严重,办案仲裁员收入微薄,精英仲裁员消极退阵,对仲裁权监督的立法不足,仲裁员责任虚化,仲裁质量及信誉下降等。我国仲裁员制度的缺陷与运行失范现象亟待矫正,应采取措施为:取消仲裁员资格的模糊性规定,建立、实行严进宽出的仲裁员淘汰机制,广泛披露仲裁员信息,取消驻会仲裁员,改革首席、独任仲裁员产生办法及仲裁报酬办法,建立相关聘任不合法仲裁员、仲裁员信息虚假公布、仲裁员过错等方面的责任追究制度等。
仲裁員隊伍是仲裁製度的脊樑,仲裁員則是仲裁的靈魂。自1995年9月1日仲裁法實施以來,我國的仲裁事業在十幾年的時間裏取得瞭長足的髮展。然而,近年來仲裁員製度的缺陷及製度運行失範亦日漸凸顯,其主要錶現為:仲裁員法定條件寬鬆,聘任仲裁員不閤條件,名冊仲裁員信息量不足,噹事人選定仲裁員盲目,選擇首席、獨任仲裁員權利落空,駐會仲裁員大量存在,仲裁訴訟化傾嚮嚴重,辦案仲裁員收入微薄,精英仲裁員消極退陣,對仲裁權鑑督的立法不足,仲裁員責任虛化,仲裁質量及信譽下降等。我國仲裁員製度的缺陷與運行失範現象亟待矯正,應採取措施為:取消仲裁員資格的模糊性規定,建立、實行嚴進寬齣的仲裁員淘汰機製,廣汎披露仲裁員信息,取消駐會仲裁員,改革首席、獨任仲裁員產生辦法及仲裁報酬辦法,建立相關聘任不閤法仲裁員、仲裁員信息虛假公佈、仲裁員過錯等方麵的責任追究製度等。
중재원대오시중재제도적척량,중재원칙시중재적령혼。자1995년9월1일중재법실시이래,아국적중재사업재십궤년적시간리취득료장족적발전。연이,근년래중재원제도적결함급제도운행실범역일점철현,기주요표현위:중재원법정조건관송,빙임중재원불합조건,명책중재원신식량불족,당사인선정중재원맹목,선택수석、독임중재원권리락공,주회중재원대량존재,중재소송화경향엄중,판안중재원수입미박,정영중재원소겁퇴진,대중재권감독적입법불족,중재원책임허화,중재질량급신예하강등。아국중재원제도적결함여운행실범현상극대교정,응채취조시위:취소중재원자격적모호성규정,건립、실행엄진관출적중재원도태궤제,엄범피로중재원신식,취소주회중재원,개혁수석、독임중재원산생판법급중재보수판법,건립상관빙임불합법중재원、중재원신식허가공포、중재원과착등방면적책임추구제도등。
The team of arbitrators is the backbone of arbitration system,while arbitrators are the soul of arbitration.The arbitration undertaking has developed fast in the past decades since the implementation of the Arbitration Law on September 1,1995.However,the defects of the arbitrator system and its operation without standard are becoming increasingly prominent.It mainly shows in the following aspects: the legal conditions for arbitrators are not strict;the employment of arbitrators doesnt’ conform to the requirements;the information for the registered arbitrators is not enough;the parties choose the arbitrators blindly;the parties dont’ have the right to choose the presiding arbitrator or the sole arbitrator;there are too many arbitrators working in the arbitration commissions;the arbitration lawsuit becomes serious;the income of the case arbitrators are low,the elite arbitrators negatively retreat;the legislation on the supervision of arbitration is not enough;the responsibility of arbitrators are becoming weak;the quality and credit of arbitration have dropped,etc.All the problems mentioned above are needed to be corrected immediately.The measures that should be taken are as follows: canceling the fuzzy rules of the arbitrator qualification,founding and implementing a strict arbitrator elimination mechanism;extensively disclosing arbitrators’information,canceling arbitrators working in the arbitration commission,reforming the election of presiding and sole arbitrators and arbitration remuneration,founding the responsibility system to deal with the cases of employing illegal arbitrators,the false announcement of arbitrator information and arbitrator fault,etc.