中国法学
中國法學
중국법학
China Legal Science
2011年
2期
27~37
,共null页
侵权责任方式 归责事由 归责原则
侵權責任方式 歸責事由 歸責原則
침권책임방식 귀책사유 귀책원칙
违反民事义务的性质决定了民事责任方式与归责原则。归责事由与归责原则既有联系,又有区别。《侵权责任法》规定了多种侵权责任方式,其归责事由与归责原则应当随之发生相应的变化。赔偿损失一般适用过错责任,法律有特别规定的,适用过错推定责任或者无过错责任。恢复原状是赔偿损失的特殊方法,其适用的归责原则与赔偿损失适用的归责原则没有区别。停止侵害、排除妨碍、消除危险与返还财产适用无过错责任(不问侵权人有无过错)。赔礼道歉、消除影响与恢复名誉适用过错责任。
違反民事義務的性質決定瞭民事責任方式與歸責原則。歸責事由與歸責原則既有聯繫,又有區彆。《侵權責任法》規定瞭多種侵權責任方式,其歸責事由與歸責原則應噹隨之髮生相應的變化。賠償損失一般適用過錯責任,法律有特彆規定的,適用過錯推定責任或者無過錯責任。恢複原狀是賠償損失的特殊方法,其適用的歸責原則與賠償損失適用的歸責原則沒有區彆。停止侵害、排除妨礙、消除危險與返還財產適用無過錯責任(不問侵權人有無過錯)。賠禮道歉、消除影響與恢複名譽適用過錯責任。
위반민사의무적성질결정료민사책임방식여귀책원칙。귀책사유여귀책원칙기유련계,우유구별。《침권책임법》규정료다충침권책임방식,기귀책사유여귀책원칙응당수지발생상응적변화。배상손실일반괄용과착책임,법률유특별규정적,괄용과착추정책임혹자무과착책임。회복원상시배상손실적특수방법,기괄용적귀책원칙여배상손실괄용적귀책원칙몰유구별。정지침해、배제방애、소제위험여반환재산괄용무과착책임(불문침권인유무과착)。배례도겸、소제영향여회복명예괄용과착책임。
The nature of breach of civil obligations determines the type of civil obligation and attributing principle. Attributable facts and attributing principle are two related different concepts. 〈 Tort Liability Law) stipulates various obligation, so the attributable facts and attributing principle should change according to obli- gation type. Damages should be applied to fault liability, if Law stipulates specifically, then presumption of fault liability or no - fault liability should be applied. Restitution is a special kind of damages, its attributing principle is same as damages'. Stopping the damage, removal of obstacles, elimination of danger and return of property should adopt non - fault liability. Apology, elimination of effects and rehabilitation should adopt fault liability.