湖南公安高等专科学校学报
湖南公安高等專科學校學報
호남공안고등전과학교학보
Journal of Huan Public Security College
2011年
2期
99~103
,共null页
行政诉讼 非法证据排除规则 法律规范 司法运用
行政訴訟 非法證據排除規則 法律規範 司法運用
행정소송 비법증거배제규칙 법률규범 사법운용
administrative litigation; exclusionary rule of illegal evidence; legal norm; judicial application
从规范、实证的角度予以观察，行政诉讼非法证据排除规则中所指的非法证据仅指违反法定程序或方式而取得的证据，即”非法取得证据”。对该种证据我国法律规范中采取原则排除加例外、严格排除和相对排除相结合的模式。从法律体系的规范层面来看，我国行政诉讼非法证据排除规则还未形成多层次的证据法律体系，在基本法律这一效力层面有待进一步突破。该规则在行政案件司法实践中的运用还远远不足，有待司法人员更深入、更大胆、更多地将其运用到具体的个案中。
從規範、實證的角度予以觀察，行政訴訟非法證據排除規則中所指的非法證據僅指違反法定程序或方式而取得的證據，即”非法取得證據”。對該種證據我國法律規範中採取原則排除加例外、嚴格排除和相對排除相結閤的模式。從法律體繫的規範層麵來看，我國行政訴訟非法證據排除規則還未形成多層次的證據法律體繫，在基本法律這一效力層麵有待進一步突破。該規則在行政案件司法實踐中的運用還遠遠不足，有待司法人員更深入、更大膽、更多地將其運用到具體的箇案中。
종규범、실증적각도여이관찰，행정소송비법증거배제규칙중소지적비법증거부지위반법정정서혹방식이취득적증거，즉”비법취득증거”。대해충증거아국법률규범중채취원칙배제가예외、엄격배제화상대배제상결합적모식。종법률체계적규범층면래간，아국행정소송비법증거배제규칙환미형성다층차적증거법률체계，재기본법률저일효력층면유대진일보돌파。해규칙재행정안건사법실천중적운용환원원불족，유대사법인원경심입、경대담、경다지장기운용도구체적개안중。
From the point of norm and demonstration, illegal evidence only refers to the evidence obtained through illegal means which violates legal procedures, namely ＂illegally obtained evidence＂. In our legal norms, this kind of evidence has been structured in the model-type that additional exceptions to the principle of exclusion, and relative exclusion combining with strictly exclusion. From the normative level of the legal system, the exclusionary nile of illegal evidence in administrative litigation has not yet formed a mtdti-level legal system, and the basic legal aspects of this effect needs further breakthrough. The use of judicial practice with the rule in administrative cases is far less, pending judicial offers further, more aggressive, more used to their specific cases.
