中国社会科学院研究生院学报
中國社會科學院研究生院學報
중국사회과학원연구생원학보
Academic Journal Graduate School Chinese Academy of Social Sciences
2011年
6期
82~86
,共null页
无权处分 合同效力 合同当事人
無權處分 閤同效力 閤同噹事人
무권처분 합동효력 합동당사인
unauthorized disposition; effect of contract; contracting parties
学界关于无权处分合同的效力，有效力待定说、无效说、有效说等诸多学说。作为通说的效力待定说认为无权处分合同的效力是一种介于有效和无效之间的模糊状态，这种认识违反了法律的确定性原则。对于无权处分合同效力有争议的原因较多，其中就有切入角度的不同。笔者更倾向于从合同当事人的角度来考察无权处分合同的效力。从无权处分合同当事人角度并区分无权处分合同最终结局的不同情形进行分析，无权处分合同实属有效合同。基于对各方当事人的利益衡量，无权处分合同也宜认定为有效合同
學界關于無權處分閤同的效力，有效力待定說、無效說、有效說等諸多學說。作為通說的效力待定說認為無權處分閤同的效力是一種介于有效和無效之間的模糊狀態，這種認識違反瞭法律的確定性原則。對于無權處分閤同效力有爭議的原因較多，其中就有切入角度的不同。筆者更傾嚮于從閤同噹事人的角度來攷察無權處分閤同的效力。從無權處分閤同噹事人角度併區分無權處分閤同最終結跼的不同情形進行分析，無權處分閤同實屬有效閤同。基于對各方噹事人的利益衡量，無權處分閤同也宜認定為有效閤同
학계관우무권처분합동적효력，유효력대정설、무효설、유효설등제다학설。작위통설적효력대정설인위무권처분합동적효력시일충개우유효화무효지간적모호상태，저충인식위반료법률적학정성원칙。대우무권처분합동효력유쟁의적원인교다，기중취유절입각도적불동。필자경경향우종합동당사인적각도래고찰무권처분합동적효력。종무권처분합동당사인각도병구분무권처분합동최종결국적불동정형진행분석，무권처분합동실속유효합동。기우대각방당사인적이익형량，무권처분합동야의인정위유효합동
Regarding the effect of the unauthorized disposition contract, there are many academic theories such as validity in suspense, invalidity, validity, and so on. As the general theory, validity in suspense insists that the effect of the unauthorized disposition contract is in a kind of fuzzy state between validity and invalidity, which is in violation of the principle of legal certainty. There are many reasons for controversy, ineluding analysis of the angle of approach. The author tends to analyze the effect of the unauthorized disposition contract from the perspective of the contracting parties, and according to the different results the unauthorized disposition contract causes, the author thinks the unauthorized disposition contract is always valid. Besides, based on measuring the interests of the parties, the unauthorized disposition contract should be recognized as a valid contract.
