CAJ | 학술논문

网络证据保全公证日益成为权利人固定侵权证据的首要选择,特别是在侵犯网络著作权案件中,网络证据保全公证往往是认定侵权能否成立的关键。但网络证据保全公证并非尽善尽美,公证过程中大量存在的瑕疵,使得公证书受到当事人的广泛质疑和反驳,如何认定有瑕疵公证书的效力成为困扰审判实践的普遍难题。在对上海市黄浦区人民法院近四年知识产权审判实践进行实证分析的基础上,对网络证据保全公证的特点以及网络公证实践中存在的瑕疵进行了分析,指出了网络证据保全公证之所以存在大量瑕疵的原因,并提出了相应的完善建议,希望对今后网络证据保全公证行业的发展有所裨益。
망락증거보전공증일익성위권리인고정침권증거적수요선택,특별시재침범망락저작권안건중,망락증거보전공증왕왕시인정침권능부성립적관건。단망락증거보전공증병비진선진미,공증과정중대량존재적하자,사득공증서수도당사인적엄범질의화반박,여하인정유하자공증서적효력성위곤우심판실천적보편난제。재대상해시황포구인민법원근사년지식산권심판실천진행실증분석적기출상,대망락증거보전공증적특점이급망락공증실천중존재적하자진행료분석,지출료망락증거보전공증지소이존재대량하자적원인,병제출료상응적완선건의,희망대금후망락증거보전공증행업적발전유소비익。
Network notarization for evidence preservation has become the first choice for the obligee to preserve tort evidence,especially in the network copyright tort cases,in which the network notarization usually is the key to determine whether the defendant implemented the infringement.However,network notarization for evidence preservation is not perfect.Many flaws in the network notarization make the notary certificate subject to wide query and refutation by the parties.How to determine the validity of the defect notary certification becomes the common difficult disturbing the trail practice.Based on the intellectual property trial practice of the shanghai huangpu district people＇s court,this paper analyzes the features of the network notarization and its flaws in trial practice.Then this paper points out the reasons why the flaws exist and puts forward some corresponding advice which will be helpful to the development of network notarization industry for evidence preservation.