浙江大学学报:人文社会科学版
浙江大學學報:人文社會科學版
절강대학학보:인문사회과학판
Journal of Zhejiang University(Humanities and Social Sciences)
2012年
3期
168~177
,共null页
北宋诗歌 乌台诗案 车盖亭诗案 崇宁文禁 诗歌转向 新旧党争 以诗议政
北宋詩歌 烏檯詩案 車蓋亭詩案 崇寧文禁 詩歌轉嚮 新舊黨爭 以詩議政
북송시가 오태시안 차개정시안 숭저문금 시가전향 신구당쟁 이시의정
Northern Song Poetry; Wutai Poetry Case; Jugaiting Poetry Case; Chongning Literary Ban; poetry development; party struggles; poems and politics discussion
诗案对诗歌的发展影响深远,是北宋诗歌和政治关系的一个重要切入点。北宋以儒立国,诗人以诗议政,发挥儒家政教精神,但屡屡因诗得祸。诗祸与新旧党争密切相连,从乌台诗案的政见之争,到车盖亭诗案的党同伐异,再到崇宁全面文禁的意气用事,始终贯穿着鲜明的政治特色。诗人的命运随着政党的得势与否而浮沉,而且波及的诗人一次比一次多。党派之间的权力之争、喜同恶异使诗人难以独善其身及保持创作的独立批评精神。诗人的创作经此连绵的政治打击,由经世致用转向寻求安身立命和追求纯粹技艺,崇宁四年(1105)后,北宋诗坛批评政治的诗歌陷入历史低谷。凡此,与北宋诗案的政治化本质而造成的负面影响息息相关。
詩案對詩歌的髮展影響深遠,是北宋詩歌和政治關繫的一箇重要切入點。北宋以儒立國,詩人以詩議政,髮揮儒傢政教精神,但屢屢因詩得禍。詩禍與新舊黨爭密切相連,從烏檯詩案的政見之爭,到車蓋亭詩案的黨同伐異,再到崇寧全麵文禁的意氣用事,始終貫穿著鮮明的政治特色。詩人的命運隨著政黨的得勢與否而浮沉,而且波及的詩人一次比一次多。黨派之間的權力之爭、喜同噁異使詩人難以獨善其身及保持創作的獨立批評精神。詩人的創作經此連綿的政治打擊,由經世緻用轉嚮尋求安身立命和追求純粹技藝,崇寧四年(1105)後,北宋詩罈批評政治的詩歌陷入歷史低穀。凡此,與北宋詩案的政治化本質而造成的負麵影響息息相關。
시안대시가적발전영향심원,시북송시가화정치관계적일개중요절입점。북송이유입국,시인이시의정,발휘유가정교정신,단루루인시득화。시화여신구당쟁밀절상련,종오태시안적정견지쟁,도차개정시안적당동벌이,재도숭저전면문금적의기용사,시종관천착선명적정치특색。시인적명운수착정당적득세여부이부침,이차파급적시인일차비일차다。당파지간적권력지쟁、희동악이사시인난이독선기신급보지창작적독립비평정신。시인적창작경차련면적정치타격,유경세치용전향심구안신립명화추구순수기예,숭저사년(1105)후,북송시단비평정치적시가함입역사저곡。범차,여북송시안적정치화본질이조성적부면영향식식상관。
This paper is a study on reciprocal relationship between the poetry legal case of Wutai Poetry Case ,Jugaiting Poetry Case ,Chongning Literary Ban and the poetic development in the Northern Song Dynasty. Since poetry legal case has far-reaching effects on poetic development, it is an important starting point to study the interrelation between poetry and politics from an in-depthinvestigation of the cases. It adopts an interdisciplinary research methodology to explore the origins, evolutions, political connotations and the artistic characteristics from political viewpoints. This paper is an in-depth research in six aspects. First, disputes in the poetry legal case are re-examined. Next, each poetic legal case is studied with emphasis on the chain reaction caused in poetry developments. Third,it investigates how scholars in the Northern Song Dynasty revived the orthodox poetic ideologies and promoted poetry physique reforms to restore elegance. Fourth, it analyzes the different types of content of political poetry and summarizes their overall artistic characteristics. Fifth, the proportion of political poems of each individual poet are collated for qualitative and quantitative analysis. Last, the paper strengthens the research on the poetry schools to deduce persuasive arguments from the perspective of their overall creative performance. The conclusion provides a concrete summary of the findings in each poetry legal case and offers further generalizations based on the regularity of several theoretical phenomena. First, it points out that the abrogation of the unceasing poem calamity events led to the retrogression of the political function of poetry to improve politics. Second, it points out that besides sharing a literary foundation,the homogeneous political views of the same poetic school helped strengthen their group consciousness. Third,it points out that Song poets played an important political role in the central government. The old and new party's political struggles were closely linked to the Wutai Poetry Case,Jugaiting Poetry Case and Chongning Literary Ban. Fourth,it summarizes the artistic characteristics of Northern Song poetry from the perspectives of political spirit and poetry functionalities. Last, it focuses on the political poems of members of the Jiayou Poets School, New Party Poets School, Su Shi Poets School and Jiangaci Poets School, and points out that the number,distribution and artistic style of poems have all been influenced by poetry legal case. It is hoped that this study will have significant reference value for research on Chinese poetry and politics in different historical periods.