湖南警察学院学报
湖南警察學院學報
호남경찰학원학보
Journal of Huan Public Security College
2012年
4期
78~83
,共null页
司法信息公开 传统公开 远程公开 启示
司法信息公開 傳統公開 遠程公開 啟示
사법신식공개 전통공개 원정공개 계시
judicial information publicity system; traditional access, remote access, inspiration
美国司法界在判例法传统下形成了较为完善的司法信息公开制度。公众对司法程序及司法记录的知情权得到保障,并通过利益衡量机制对公众知情权进行了必要的限制。但是信息时代背景下远程公开方式对美国传统的司法信息公开制度带来了挑战,在各方争论中,美国司法界采取有限制的远程公开思路,按照信息内容、案件类型区别公开,并利用XML技术对敏感信息进行识别、处理。当前,我国的司法信息公开制度处于传统司法信息公开与远程司法信息公开交错发展的新阶段,传统司法信息公开尚未建立健全,远程司法信息公开的挑战却又如期而至,因此美国的经验值得我们借鉴。
美國司法界在判例法傳統下形成瞭較為完善的司法信息公開製度。公衆對司法程序及司法記錄的知情權得到保障,併通過利益衡量機製對公衆知情權進行瞭必要的限製。但是信息時代揹景下遠程公開方式對美國傳統的司法信息公開製度帶來瞭挑戰,在各方爭論中,美國司法界採取有限製的遠程公開思路,按照信息內容、案件類型區彆公開,併利用XML技術對敏感信息進行識彆、處理。噹前,我國的司法信息公開製度處于傳統司法信息公開與遠程司法信息公開交錯髮展的新階段,傳統司法信息公開尚未建立健全,遠程司法信息公開的挑戰卻又如期而至,因此美國的經驗值得我們藉鑒。
미국사법계재판례법전통하형성료교위완선적사법신식공개제도。공음대사법정서급사법기록적지정권득도보장,병통과이익형량궤제대공음지정권진행료필요적한제。단시신식시대배경하원정공개방식대미국전통적사법신식공개제도대래료도전,재각방쟁론중,미국사법계채취유한제적원정공개사로,안조신식내용、안건류형구별공개,병이용XML기술대민감신식진행식별、처리。당전,아국적사법신식공개제도처우전통사법신식공개여원정사법신식공개교착발전적신계단,전통사법신식공개상미건립건전,원정사법신식공개적도전각우여기이지,인차미국적경험치득아문차감。
American judiciary has already formed a relatively perfect system of access to judicial information by case law. Public's right to know about judicial process and records had been protected, and it had been restricted by the mechanism of balancing interests. However, in this Information Age, the remote access brought about much challenge for traditional access to judicial informatiom. After much arguing, the American judiciary adopted limited reinote access, that is, distinguishing the judicial information according to different content of information and different type of cases, and using XML technology to identify and deal with sensitive information. At present, China's judicial information publicity system is still in the early stage and it has more defects in remote access. So it is worthy to learn from the American experience.