社会科学
社會科學
사회과학
Journal of Social Sciences
2012年
11期
141~147
,共null页
欧洲中心论 加州学派 经济史
歐洲中心論 加州學派 經濟史
구주중심론 가주학파 경제사
Europe - Centered Approach; California School; Economic History
近年加州学派对于前近代东西方经济史的比较研究引起了国内外学术界的广泛反响,关于“欧洲中心论”的讨论是其中引人关注的问题之一。由于对于“欧洲中心论”并没有一个广为接受的定义,相关研究和评论在这一问题上显示出纷繁混乱的局面。实际上,对于“欧洲中心论”存在着两种颇为对立的理解:一种强调的是历史发展的普遍性,另一种强调的则是历史发展的特殊性。理解加州学派谈及“欧洲中心论”时的实际含义,对于合理评价其历史诠释学有着重要的意义。
近年加州學派對于前近代東西方經濟史的比較研究引起瞭國內外學術界的廣汎反響,關于“歐洲中心論”的討論是其中引人關註的問題之一。由于對于“歐洲中心論”併沒有一箇廣為接受的定義,相關研究和評論在這一問題上顯示齣紛繁混亂的跼麵。實際上,對于“歐洲中心論”存在著兩種頗為對立的理解:一種彊調的是歷史髮展的普遍性,另一種彊調的則是歷史髮展的特殊性。理解加州學派談及“歐洲中心論”時的實際含義,對于閤理評價其歷史詮釋學有著重要的意義。
근년가주학파대우전근대동서방경제사적비교연구인기료국내외학술계적엄범반향,관우“구주중심론”적토론시기중인인관주적문제지일。유우대우“구주중심론”병몰유일개엄위접수적정의,상관연구화평론재저일문제상현시출분번혼란적국면。실제상,대우“구주중심론”존재착량충파위대립적리해:일충강조적시역사발전적보편성,령일충강조적칙시역사발전적특수성。리해가주학파담급“구주중심론”시적실제함의,대우합리평개기역사전석학유착중요적의의。
In recent years, scholars of California School have gained much regards for their comparative studies between Eastern and Western history of economy in pre -modern times and the "divergence" of the two economic systems. Discussion of "Europe - centered Approaches" is one of the most important and controversial thesis in their research. Yet, because the notion "Europe -centered Approach" itself doesn't have a precise and wildly - accepted definition, researches and criticisms on the thesis seem to be somewhat confusing. In fact, there are two opposite understanding of "Europe -centered Approach": one emphasizes the universality of history; the other emphasizes the particularity of history. When evaluating the historical explanation of California School, it' s important to understand firstly what they mean when they use the word "Europe -centered Approach".