法律科学：西北政法学院学报
法律科學：西北政法學院學報
법률과학：서북정법학원학보
Science of Law
2012年
6期
139~145
,共null页
教唆犯 二重性 教唆行为 犯罪预备行为 立法技术
教唆犯 二重性 教唆行為 犯罪預備行為 立法技術
교사범 이중성 교사행위 범죄예비행위 입법기술
abetting; the dual character; instigating behavior; preparatory criminal acts; legislative technology
作为我国教唆犯本质属性通说的二重性说,将教唆犯的成立根据与处罚根据混为一谈,以行为的评价等同责任的认定,具有方法论上的错误。二重性说这一概念采用双重的划分标准,将一个概念在同一视角下同时解释为两个以上相反的意义,违反了理论研究的逻辑规则,不仅有损刑法理论结构的协调性,也有违刑法规范的同一性。二重性说违背我国现阶段的刑事政策、脱离社会事实基础并导致操作规则的混乱,存在诸多理论暗礁。犯罪预备性才是教唆行为的本质属性,教唆犯的属性取决于对犯罪预备行为的立法技术。
作為我國教唆犯本質屬性通說的二重性說,將教唆犯的成立根據與處罰根據混為一談,以行為的評價等同責任的認定,具有方法論上的錯誤。二重性說這一概唸採用雙重的劃分標準,將一箇概唸在同一視角下同時解釋為兩箇以上相反的意義,違反瞭理論研究的邏輯規則,不僅有損刑法理論結構的協調性,也有違刑法規範的同一性。二重性說違揹我國現階段的刑事政策、脫離社會事實基礎併導緻操作規則的混亂,存在諸多理論暗礁。犯罪預備性纔是教唆行為的本質屬性,教唆犯的屬性取決于對犯罪預備行為的立法技術。
작위아국교사범본질속성통설적이중성설,장교사범적성립근거여처벌근거혼위일담,이행위적평개등동책임적인정,구유방법론상적착오。이중성설저일개념채용쌍중적화분표준,장일개개념재동일시각하동시해석위량개이상상반적의의,위반료이론연구적라집규칙,불부유손형법이론결구적협조성,야유위형법규범적동일성。이중성설위배아국현계단적형사정책、탈리사회사실기출병도치조작규칙적혼란,존재제다이론암초。범죄예비성재시교사행위적본질속성,교사범적속성취결우대범죄예비행위적입법기술。
As the essential attribute of the dual character of the abetting,it is said that the establishment of abetting in accordance with the punishment and evaluation of the behavior just as recognition of an equal responsibility,the methodology of which is wrong.The concept of the duality use dual standards and explain the abetting at the same time as two or more opposite meaning,which violating the logical rules of theoretical research and undermine the structure of the coordination of criminal law theory.The theory of dual character of abetting violates the current Chinese policy,deviate from social reality and leads to the chaos of the operating rules.Preparatory criminal act is the essential attribute of abetting behavior,the property of abettor depends on the legislative techniques on preparatory criminal acts.
