河南科技大学学报：社会科学版
河南科技大學學報：社會科學版
하남과기대학학보：사회과학판
Journal of Henan University of Science & Technology:Social science
2012年
6期
105~110
,共null页
行政裁量基准 行政规则 司法审查 裁量正义
行政裁量基準 行政規則 司法審查 裁量正義
행정재량기준 행정규칙 사법심사 재량정의
administrative discretion standard; administrative rules; judicial review; discretion justice
行政裁量基准是行政法的法源,将其纳入司法审查具有必然性。但司法审查的实践势必面临审查＂依据＂与＂对象＂、行政理性与司法理性、成文基准与非成文基准之间抉择的两难。审查的指导理念从＂浪漫与怀疑＂到＂现实＂、审查模式从静态向动态转变、价值目标追求从被动守护正义到能动回应现实,是走出尴尬的基本途径。
行政裁量基準是行政法的法源,將其納入司法審查具有必然性。但司法審查的實踐勢必麵臨審查＂依據＂與＂對象＂、行政理性與司法理性、成文基準與非成文基準之間抉擇的兩難。審查的指導理唸從＂浪漫與懷疑＂到＂現實＂、審查模式從靜態嚮動態轉變、價值目標追求從被動守護正義到能動迴應現實,是走齣尷尬的基本途徑。
행정재량기준시행정법적법원,장기납입사법심사구유필연성。단사법심사적실천세필면림심사＂의거＂여＂대상＂、행정이성여사법이성、성문기준여비성문기준지간결택적량난。심사적지도이념종＂랑만여부의＂도＂현실＂、심사모식종정태향동태전변、개치목표추구종피동수호정의도능동회응현실,시주출감개적기본도경。
Being the sources of administrative law,the administrative discretion standard is inevitable to be put in the judicial review.The practice of judicial review is in a dilemma of choices such as ＂basis＂ or ＂object＂,administrative rationality or judicial rational,written standard or unwritten standard,etc.The basic way to overcome the embarrassing situation is to turn the ideas of judicial review from ＂romance and doubt＂ to ＂reality＂,to transform review mode from static state to dynamic,and to move the aims from passive guardian justice to active response to reality.
