国际商务研究
國際商務研究
국제상무연구
International Business Research
2013年
1期
37~46
,共null页
出口退税 钢铁产品 倍差法 经验研究
齣口退稅 鋼鐵產品 倍差法 經驗研究
출구퇴세 강철산품 배차법 경험연구
export tax rebate; steel products; difference on difference; empirical research
本文采用HS分类的第72章钢铁产品六分位数据,用“倍差法”分别检验了出口退税政策变动对中国向世界和中国向韩国钢铁出口规模和结构的影响。实证结果表明,2010年7月中国政府取消出口退税政策显著地抑制了相关商品的出口增长:取消出口退税的四大类商品对世界的出口增长率比未取消退税的商品低了54%~98%,对韩国的出口增长率比未取消的其他商品低了30%~69%,为改善钢铁产品出口结构起到了重要的作用。由于一定时期内特定国家的贸易政策、汇率变动等影响需求的因素较为稳定,因此对韩国出口的实证研究结果更能客观地反映政策的实际效果。
本文採用HS分類的第72章鋼鐵產品六分位數據,用“倍差法”分彆檢驗瞭齣口退稅政策變動對中國嚮世界和中國嚮韓國鋼鐵齣口規模和結構的影響。實證結果錶明,2010年7月中國政府取消齣口退稅政策顯著地抑製瞭相關商品的齣口增長:取消齣口退稅的四大類商品對世界的齣口增長率比未取消退稅的商品低瞭54%~98%,對韓國的齣口增長率比未取消的其他商品低瞭30%~69%,為改善鋼鐵產品齣口結構起到瞭重要的作用。由于一定時期內特定國傢的貿易政策、彙率變動等影響需求的因素較為穩定,因此對韓國齣口的實證研究結果更能客觀地反映政策的實際效果。
본문채용HS분류적제72장강철산품륙분위수거,용“배차법”분별검험료출구퇴세정책변동대중국향세계화중국향한국강철출구규모화결구적영향。실증결과표명,2010년7월중국정부취소출구퇴세정책현저지억제료상관상품적출구증장:취소출구퇴세적사대류상품대세계적출구증장솔비미취소퇴세적상품저료54%~98%,대한국적출구증장솔비미취소적기타상품저료30%~69%,위개선강철산품출구결구기도료중요적작용。유우일정시기내특정국가적무역정책、회솔변동등영향수구적인소교위은정,인차대한국출구적실증연구결과경능객관지반영정책적실제효과。
In this paper, we examine the impact on the amount and structure of China's steel export after cancelling tax rebate policy using a new method, "difference on difference" , and 6-bit export data (Chap.72 under HS classification). The empirical study shows that the cancelling of tax rebate policy in July 2010 significantly suppressed the export of concerned products. Among the four categories of products, the export growth appears significantly different. The export growth of control group (eliminated tax rebates products) appears 54% to 98% lower than the compared group when we study China's world trade, while 30% to 69% lower when we take Sino- ROK trade as an example. Considering the stable influence on the demand of a certain country, such as trade policy, exchange rate and other factors, we think the empirical results of Sino-ROK can reflect the actual effects of tax rebate policy more objectively.